I Loved Him First, Then Left

I Loved Him First, Then Left cover

I Loved Him First, Then Left

My mom ended up with her childhood sweetheartโ€”heโ€™s fifteen years older than me, a proper older man.

Dating an older man hasโ€ฆ overall, not been a great experience.

Becauseโ€ฆ he doesnโ€™t love me.

My mom worships love. She had me at twenty-two after a forbidden fling, and Ethan Grant is seven years younger than she is.

Maybe because I grew up without a father, Iโ€™ve secretly liked this man whoโ€™s fifteen years older than me for a long time.

Ethan Grant is thirty-five this year. Heโ€™s been chasing my mom for years with no luck, and heโ€™s still single.

Today, pushed by his family, he went on a blind date.

He told me the woman seemed niceโ€”delicate features, polite, good family background and educationโ€”but he just didnโ€™t feel a spark.

So after the date he told her bluntly they werenโ€™t a match. That set off a huge fight at home; his father even threatened to disown him.

That afternoon, restless and in a foul mood, he came over to my place to drink with my mom. Only she had to pick up an extra night shift last minute, so it was just me home.

Ethan warned me to be careful by myself, then was about to leave. I called after him.

I bit my lip, mustered my courage, and said, โ€œEthan, stayโ€”let me drink with you.โ€

Iโ€™ve always been rude about it and called him by his name since I was little. My mom scolded me a few times at first, but after a while they all got used to it.

Ethan stood by the window looking at me. His shirt was buttoned down to the third button, a slice of collarbone showing. The sunset draped a soft golden halo over his brow.

They say time is ruthless, but it had been oddly kind to Ethan.

He was thirty-five, but in a white shirt he looked no older than a twenty-something kid.

He smiled. โ€œYou can drink?โ€

I tilted my chin. โ€œOf course! Iโ€™m the drinking god at Riverside Manufacturing!โ€

Iโ€™d always hated school. I dropped out after high school and went straight to the factory.

I made Ethan laugh. He waved his hand, โ€œCome on, Uncle Carl will treat you to dinner.โ€

He wanted to take me to a steakhouse, but I refused.

I knew he could afford it, but I didnโ€™t want to spend his money. I hate those placesโ€”always makes me feel trapped.

So I dragged Ethan to the Riverside Market Grill along the street. Late summer into early fallโ€”skewers and booze felt right.

Ethan and I always had good conversation. He knew a lot. Whether I was tossing around the little bit of literary trivia I knew, or gushing over the latest heartthrob, he could jump in and argue the point with me.

Honestly, I didnโ€™t understand why my mom never liked him.

Iโ€™d casually asked her, โ€œMom, Ethanโ€™s so greatโ€”why have you refused him all these years?โ€

She just smiled softly, and gave me six words: โ€œNot right for me. I donโ€™t like him.โ€

That was so herโ€”my mom is the most free-spirited woman I know.

In her twenties she fell wildly in love, but she chose wrongโ€”he turned out to be a jerk. When she became pregnant, the man ran away and never came back. She decided to raise me alone, and never chased another partner.

Thereโ€™s a fierce kind of independence about her. If she loves, she loves; if sheโ€™s wrong, she takes responsibility. Because of that, we all knew she truly didnโ€™t love Ethan. She would rather be single for twenty years than settle.

That night Ethan and I talked about everythingโ€”except the fact that I liked him.

Maybe because we drank, Ethan loosened up more than usual. He discarded some of his composed, polite air, tugged his collar open, and told me amusing stories from work.

When something was funny he laughed out loud. He felt more real that way.

We drank a lot and talked a lot.

By the end we were drunk. Ethan paid the bill and said heโ€™d walk me home.

I clung to his arm. โ€œNoโ€”if my mom finds out I drank sheโ€™ll scold me!โ€

With my pouting, he brought me back to his place.

I texted my mom that Iโ€™d be sleeping at the Riverside Dorms tonight.

It wasnโ€™t my first time at Ethanโ€™s. I slipped into his slippers like it was nothing, rummaged through his closet for something to wear, and took a shower.

Afterward I put on one of his oversized shirts. It was longโ€”just covered my hips. When I came out and sat on the couch to sober up, Ethan froze.

He blinked, cheeks flushing, and turned his head away. โ€œPut on your own clothes.โ€

I sat beside him and fluttered my lashes. โ€œMine are all wet from the shower.โ€

The living room was dim. I leaned into him and saw his Adamโ€™s apple bob.

He pursed his lips and suddenly stood. โ€œIโ€™ll go buy you something.โ€

โ€œNo!โ€ I protested, then reached out and grabbed his wrist, standing up too.

โ€œEthan.โ€ The booze gave me courage. I tugged his arm and pressed closer. โ€œAm I pretty?โ€

He hesitated, then studied my face carefully before finally admitting, โ€œYes. Pretty.โ€

I know Iโ€™m not uglyโ€”I took after my mom. People have always said Iโ€™m good-looking.

I moved closer and, climbing his arm with my fingertips, asked quietly, โ€œDo I look like my mom?โ€

Ethan stiffened.

Of course he understood what I was doing. A grown man; he knew I was trying to seduce him.

He pushed me away after a few seconds, brow furrowed. โ€œMaya, do you know what youโ€™re doing?โ€

โ€œI do!โ€ I was flushed and buzzing from the alcohol, heat running through me. I tilted my head up. โ€œEthan, I like you.โ€

He stared for a long time, then swept his sleeve and left. โ€œThis is nonsense.โ€

He went into his room. My courage, so hard-won, evaporated in an instant.

Nonsense? How is this nonsense? Two unmarried adultsโ€”if itโ€™s mutual, whatโ€™s wrong with that?

I sulked into the spare bedroom next door.

It was quiet beside me. I waited and waited, but Ethan never came. I left the door open and fell asleep without a blanket.

When I woke, Ethan was standing at the bedside. โ€œGet up. Take some medicineโ€”you have a fever.โ€

I felt awfulโ€”dizzy, freezing. I clung to him and sat up, obediently taking fever medicine.

He tucked the blanket around me and handed me a thermometer. I took it, but on purpose tugged the collar down and shoved it into my armpit. When the collar slipped, I noticed his breathing deepen, then he suddenly turned his head away.

My temperature read 38.6ยฐC.

After some coaxing, Ethan stayed to take care of me.

Late that night, the liquor still in me, I felt cold even under the covers. I grabbed at him, mumbling, โ€œColdโ€ฆโ€

Half-asleep, my hand fumbled and caught his collar. I yanked.

Ethan, unprepared, bent forwardโ€”right into my reach.

I opened my eyes. He was a breath away. I could feel the warm rush of his breath. He was nervous; his breathing quickened. My heart skipped.

Fueled by the alcohol, I went for it. I tilted my head and kissed him.

It was late. We were alone. Alcohol and suppressed feelings finally erupted. Sparks caught.

Thenโ€ฆwe slept together.

The next morning I woke naked in his arms; Ethan was still asleep. I froze, watching the side of his face, terrified to wake him.

More than anything, I was afraid of what would happen next.

How would he react when he woke? Shocked? Angry? Regretful?

I was thinking that when his lashes fluttered and he opened his eyes.

Panic flooded me. I tried to pretend I was still asleep, but it was too lateโ€”our eyes met.

He sat bolt upright, shocked and flusteredโ€”more than Iโ€™d expected.

He practically jumped out of bed, only to realize he wasnโ€™t wearing any clothes. For the first time in all the years Iโ€™d known him, he looked truly panicked.

He grabbed some clothes and dressed quickly, then frowned and looked down at me. โ€œMayaโ€ฆlast nightโ€ฆโ€

He started, ashamed, like someone whoโ€™d done wrong.

I cut him off. I looked up at him. โ€œEthan, will you take responsibility?โ€

His body stiffened. His lips trembled, but he didnโ€™t say a word.

I knew he wouldnโ€™t. I donโ€™t doubt Ethanโ€™s characterโ€”if it had been any other woman, he probably would have stepped up. But Iโ€™m different. Iโ€™m the daughter of the woman heโ€™s loved for most of his life. He canโ€™t face that.

Still, I truly liked him. Even seeing him struggle made me feel conflicted.

I forced a laugh and shrugged, pretending to be casual. โ€œForget it. I was just teasing. You donโ€™t have to take responsibility.โ€

Ethan still looked tornโ€”pained and guilty.

I told him Iโ€™d rest and gently pushed him out of the room.

Once the door closed, the tears came. I thought being physically close meant being together. Guess I was naive.

But I donโ€™t regret last nightโ€”not for now. I know the cost of impulsive loveโ€”my mom raised me through hardshipโ€”but maybe I inherited a bit of her temperament. If I love, Iโ€™ll dive in headfirst.

My mom is even more stubborn than I am though. For someone she doesnโ€™t love, no matter how much you pour your heart out sheโ€™ll just frown and say thanks.

Thatโ€™s Ethan. Heโ€™ll never stand beside my mom. If thatโ€™s the truth, then why not try? Theyโ€™re both unmarriedโ€”I donโ€™t believe I canโ€™t win him.

Once I thought that through, I felt lighter.

I checked the time, got up, took a shower, changed, and went downstairs to buy breakfast.

Ethan never left his bedroom the whole time.

I peered at the doorโ€”no light on inside, everything silent.

I set the breakfast on the table, left a sticky note, and left.

Work waits. No matter what happens, you go in first thing.

All day I was distracted. Bits and pieces of last night kept flashing through my mind.

Because I was drunk, a lot of details were fuzzy, but there were still moments that made my face burn and my heart race.

I had this feeling we weren’t completely doneโ€”Ethan and I.

Sure enough.

A few days later my mom announced something out of the blueโ€”she was seeing someone.

She said this โ€œuncleโ€ wanted to take Ethan and me to dinner. I agreed right away.

My mom had been single for so many years; if she finally found someone, of course I should be supportive.

Still, I worried about Ethan.

That night.

A relatively well-known private bistro, in a private room.

After work I changed and happily went to the dinner. When I pushed open the door I froze.

My momโ€™s new boyfriend was warm and came to shake my handโ€”friendly but careful. But he looked nothing like what Iโ€™d imagined. Iโ€™d thought sheโ€™d find a polished, successful, refined man.

Instead, standing there was a big, burly guy with tattoos all up his armsโ€”a kind of local tough.

But he smiled at me in such a pleased, slightly embarrassed way that the contrast made him oddly endearing.

Sensing my hesitation, my mom linked her arm through his and introduced him with a smile. โ€œThis is your Uncle Carl. Heโ€™s a good man, and heโ€™s very sweet.โ€

I nodded and obediently called him Uncle Carl.

When my mom complimented him, the tough-looking guy flushed and scratched his head in embarrassment.

Then the private room door openedโ€”Ethan walked in.

The mood shifted.

Ethan froze for a moment when he saw the man my mom was linked with.

But he quickly composed himself, walked over, and shook Uncle Carlโ€™s hand without making a scene.

โ€œHello, Ethan,โ€ Uncle Carl said, still warm and friendly. He chatted a bit. โ€œLena mentioned youโ€”said you take good care of her and Maya. Thank you.โ€

Ethanโ€™s face was unreadable. โ€œWeโ€™ve been friends a long time. Itโ€™s what friends do.โ€

They sat down.

My mom naturally sat next to Uncle Carl; I deliberately took the seat beside Ethan.

He blinked but didnโ€™t protest.

My mom was used to itโ€”ever since I was little I liked to stick close to Ethan and slide in beside him at meals.

As the dinner went on, my mom had been right.

Uncle Carl might look rough, but he was a really good manโ€”thoughtful, attentive to my mom, jovial, quick with a comeback, polite to the waitstaff. You could tell he respected people and that he loved my mom.

By the end of the meal I liked him a lot more than I expected.

Ethan, though, stayed quiet. If you didnโ€™t speak to him, he barely said anything.

Seeing the couple opposite us all lovey-dovey made Ethan look even lonelier. I pursed my lips and got a little mischievous.

Under the table I nudged the top of his foot with my toes.

Ethan stiffened.

I grinned and casually turned my head as if looking out the window behind him, then let my toes trace up his ankle.

His legs tensed harder, and suddenly his hand slipped under the table and tapped my thigh.

He scowled at meโ€”warning written all over his eyes.

I smiled and grabbed his hand, squeezing until our fingers entwined.

Ethanโ€™s composed face immediately lost its calm.

The first half of dinner was fairly calm: my mom and Uncle Carl tossed compliments back and forth, Ethan stayed silent, and I happily played the role of sugar-fan.

Later, under the table, Ethan and I held hands.

He eventually tacitly accepted it.

Why no one across the table noticed? Iโ€™m left-handed and happened to sit to Ethanโ€™s left, so my right hand held his left. Weโ€™d occasionally pick up food with our other handsโ€”no one saw anything odd.

More importantly, the couple opposite were wrapped up in each otherโ€”who would pay attention to us?

But as I quietly stared at our joined hands, a thought hit me.

What if he was doing this out of spite?

Finding my momโ€™s new boyfriend shocked and hurt himโ€”maybe he silently agreed to hold my hand as a way to get back at me.

That stung. Still, I didnโ€™t want to argue. Iโ€™d liked him for so long; as long as I could be with him, I didnโ€™t care why.

Dinner continued with two couples feeling very different things.

At one point Ethan got up to go to the restroom. I stood too and called out like it was nothing, โ€œIโ€™m going too!โ€

I followed him out of the room, acting casual.

He walked fast; I kept up. We crossed the long corridor and reached the restroom door.

Ethan was about to push into the menโ€™s room when I grabbed him.

I steeled myself and leaned close to his ear. โ€œEthan, can I come to your place tonight?โ€

Ethan was easy to tease; I knew that.

Just that question in the empty hall made his ears go pink.

He took a deep breath, turned to me, and said with heavy seriousness, โ€œMaya, letโ€™s end this. I was drunk that night…โ€

Heโ€™d barely started when I cut in. โ€œEthan, my mom already found a boyfriendโ€”what are you waiting for?โ€

He stared at me.

I reached forward, took his hand, and put it against my cheek. โ€œPeople always say my mom and I look so much alike. Look.โ€

I softened my voice. โ€œDo I look like her?โ€

He couldnโ€™t refuse. He glanced at me, then away. โ€œDo you?โ€

He pursed his lips and finally said, โ€œYou do.โ€

I pushed while things were warm. โ€œThen let me come over tonight. Okay?โ€

As adults, we both knew what that line meant. Ethan was quiet a long time, then finally relented. He looked me in the eyes, though his brow was tight. โ€œOkay.โ€

When he said it I smiled, let go of his hand, and said, โ€œGo to the bathroom. Iโ€™ll wait here.โ€

He seemed like he wanted to say more. His lips moved, but he didnโ€™t speak and walked into the menโ€™s room.

The instant he turned away, my smile vanished.

I knew as clearly as anything we were on different paths now. There was no turning back.

I was gambling my whole life on this.

And from the moment he agreed to let me go to his placeโ€”no matter whyโ€”my odds were sunk.

Worried and restless, I stood by the restroom corridor and lit a cigarette.

Sometimes I thought my life had no futureโ€”no degree, started at the plant at twenty, gave my youth and body to the work, and the person I loved didnโ€™t love me back.

A third of the cigarette gone, Ethan walked out.

He blinked, then hurried over, snatched the cigarette from my hand, and scolded with a sternness that felt almost parental. โ€œDonโ€™t smoke!โ€

I tilted my chin and winked. โ€œMy mom smokes.โ€

He paused, looked at me, said nothing, then took the half-smoked cigarette, drew two puffs like it was nothing, and crushed it in a nearby trash can.

He dropped the butt, looked down at me, and said, โ€œLetโ€™s go back. Theyโ€™ll worry if weโ€™re gone too long.โ€

I nodded and followed him.

All the way I stared at his back.

Sometimes you just canโ€™t figure out your momโ€™s taste. She passed up a guy as good as Ethan and chose a rough-looking tough. Fate between people is weird like that, I guess.

The rest of the meal was simple. My mom and Uncle Carl kept diking on each other, Ethan kept quiet, and I ate with my head down.

The air felt calm but with a thin thread of awkwardness.

Suddenly there was a peeled shrimp in my bowl.

I blinked and looked up. Ethan was peeling the second shrimp.

Almost instinctively I glanced at my mom and Uncle Carlโ€”completely unfazed. My mom teased, โ€œEthan, sheโ€™s never dated anyone; youโ€™ve spoiled her. If she starts looking for men by your standards, sheโ€™ll never find anyone.โ€

I looped my arm through Ethanโ€™s and joked, โ€œThen if I canโ€™t find someone later, Iโ€™ll just cling to him!โ€

My mom glared and laughed at me for being disrespectful.

They all took it as a joke. Only I knew Ethanโ€™s fingers had gone stiff for a second as he peeled the shrimp.

After the meal, Uncle Carl went to payโ€”but Ethan had already settled the bill.

Uncle Carl looked puzzled. Ethan finally smiled tonightโ€”the first one Iโ€™d seenโ€”and said, โ€œItโ€™s just a meal. Who pays doesnโ€™t matter. From now on, please take care of Lena.โ€

It was an odd, almost entrusted thing to say, but Uncle Carl, bless him, didnโ€™t read into it. He grumbled about not letting Ethan pay and promised heโ€™d take care of my mom.

Watching their affectionate exchange, I did my best not to be an extra at this romance.

I waved my hand and told my mom, "You two go ahead. I’ll head back to the dorm tonight."

Then, trying to sound casual, I patted Ethan’s arm. "Have Ethan drive me back."

Mom nodded and didn’t press the issue.

Uncle Carl didn’t take the carโ€”whether he even had one, I didn’t know. I know my mom: once she sets her heart on someone, she doesn’t care about practicalities. If she decides a man is the one, she’d follow him holding a bowl even if he went begging.

She and Uncle Carl looked like two kids in love, hand in hand as they walked into Maplewood Station.

Only when their figures disappeared did I turn and loop my arm through Ethan’s.

"Stop staring, Ethan. Let’s go home."

"Mm."

He answered softly, slowly looking away. He let me hook my arm through his and started toward the parking lot.

Driving home.

Riding in the passenger seat, I had this strange little illusionโ€”like maybe I really was Ethan’s girlfriend now, sitting beside him in the fading evening light on the way home.

We didn’t speak the whole way.

Park, get out, go inside.

We shut the door behind us and neither of us went in first. We didn’t turn on the light.

The door slammed shut behind us, and Ethan stood in front of me without a word.

He seemed… hesitant.

I knew Mom’s new relationship had struck him hard. I knew he hadn’t been able to get past that night when we were together. But I didn’t want to give myself time to hesitateโ€”I feared that if I hesitated, I’d lose my chance to be with him for good.

So in the dimness I stepped forward and wrapped my arms around his waist.

Ethan’s breathing deepened.

"Ethan."

I whispered his name in the dark. "Hold me."

All these years I’d always called him by his full name.

He was silent for a few seconds, then, obediently, he held me.

His palm settled at my lower backโ€”hot, heavy.

I tilted my head up and rose onto my toes, pressing my lips to his.

Ethan’s lips were so softโ€”warm and tender.

I tentatively slipped out the tip of my tongue and traced it along his lips. He was quiet a beat, then the hand at my back tightened. He swooped me into his arms, carrying me sideways toward the bedroom.

I looped my legs around his waist and clung to his neck. I could tell he was moved.

It struck me then: in the grown-up world, the first step matters so much. Once you take it, the second and third steps often follow naturally.

Ethan set me down at the edge of the bed and loosened his collar. Moonlight slanted through the window as he looked at me, his voice low, threaded with a soft pant.

"Maya, have you thought it through?"

I didn’t answer with words. I grabbed his hand and kissed him as he leaned downโ€”an action that was my answer.

When girls open to their feelings, they might feel for many boys. I never did.

From that first flutter to now, I’ve only ever liked one person.

He was holding me in the dark, arms tight around my waist.

I’d dropped out and been working for over two years. Plenty of guys at Riverside Manufacturing chased me, but I’d never let any of them in. I was waiting for someoneโ€”waiting for someone to accept me.

That night we let ourselves go.

Ethan held me close and I returned his passion. We spent the night wrapped up in each other.

I knew there was no turning back, yet I couldn’t be sure… would Ethan give me a future?

Late, when he was propped over me, nuzzling my ear, he murmured, "Maya, you’re beautiful."

"You’re beautiful"โ€”not "I love you."

In that faint moonlight I stared into his eyes and held back the urge to ask if I looked like her.

I must have been crazy to compare myself to my mom in a moment like that. But the thought that he might still be thinking of someone else twisted me up inside.

At dawn my phone buzzed.

I blinked awake, slipped from Ethan’s arms, and fished my phone from under the pillow.

The screen showed a single caller: Mom.

Ethan’s sleep vanished the instant he glimpsed it; he sat up straight.

I steadied myself and answered. "Hello?"

My mom’s voice on the line was bright, full of the kind of happiness you get from new love. "Maya, I’m at the factory gate. This morning Uncle Carl made your favorite savory pork-and-preserved-egg congee and I bought some steamed soup dumplings. Come grab them, okay?"

Even though I wasn’t on speaker, her voice floated clearly in the room.

Ethan stiffened noticeably.

For some reason, seeing him like that made me want to tease him.

I gripped the phone and called out, "I’m not at the factory. I’m with Ethan."

Ethan’s reaction was dramaticโ€”he lurched up, shock on his face.

Look at thatโ€”the usually calm Ethan had his own blush-and-panic moment. He looked like a man caught in the wrong bed.

My mom was surprised. "You’re with him?"

I shot Ethan a playful look, then, meeting his warning gaze, smiled and said smoothly, "They say the steamed dumplings downstairs are really good. I asked Ethan to buy some for me, but he refused, so I had to come get them myself."

It sounded so like me that Mom didn’t doubt it. She’d long ago gotten used to my impulsive cravingsโ€”I’d once ridden an hour across town just for a slice of thick-cut fried yogurt.

She told Uncle Carl where she’d left the breakfast at the factory and hung up.

I put the phone away and looked at Ethan.

He didn’t look pleased.

For once he wore a shadowed expressionโ€”stiff, eyes downcast. For a moment his gaze made my heart race.

"Ethan…"

I grabbed his wrist and gave it a little shake, trying to be sweet.

I wasn’t fully focusedโ€”the night had been too intense. We had only washed up quickly before sleeping. Ethan, wearing only boxer shorts, had his chest bare; his muscles were tight in the moonlight, and I couldn’t help stealing a glance.

But my fingers on his arm were jerked away.

In all these years, it was the first time I’d seen Ethan angry. He shot me a cold look, scooped up the scattered clothes from the floor, and left the room.

"Bang!"

The bedroom door slammed. I shivered and snapped back to reality.

Ethan was really angry. Over something as trivial as my teasing?

I couldn’t make sense of it. I pulled on the nearest shirt, then went to his bedroom door and knocked.

"Knock knockโ€”"

Silence.

I tried calling, "Ethan!" but got no answer.

I felt an odd prick of stubbornness and grabbed my phone, heading out. As I left, I slammed the door shut on purpose.

The heavy sound made my stomach drop.

People are strange. Before we slept together I had told myself I would ask for nothingโ€”just being near him would be enough. But now that we actually were together, my expectations had shifted in ways I hadn’t anticipated.

At the elevator I glanced back. The hallway was quiet; Ethan hadn’t even opened the door to watch me go.

The elevator doors opened and I sighed as I stepped in.

Halfway down the block, I paused and looked up at his apartment window. I could have sworn a shadow flitted past the curtain, then it was empty when I blinked.

I couldn’t focus the whole workday. All I could see was the expression Ethan had given meโ€”the coldness in his final glance.

Was he really that upset? I felt guilty and petty at the same time.

And of course, misery attracts people.

Tony Shenโ€”one of the line workersโ€”had been pursuing me for months. He’s decent enough but mouthy. He’d been out today on leave, but as I neared the factory gate he staggered into view reeking of alcohol.

He slurred greetings at me. I gave a curt nod and tried to hurry past. I still had the urge to go back to Ethan’s place to see if he’d come out.

Tony grabbed my wrist. He was close, breath heavy with booze. "Maya, I’ve been the loyal one for ages. You owe me something today, right?"

Gooseflesh climbed my arms. I shrugged his hand away. "What do you want?"

Tony’s used his connection to the Plant Manager to act like a bully. At the gate, people pretended not to notice him clinging to me.

He was wasted and careless. He flashed a lecherous grin, stepped closer, and reached for my waist. I dodged instinctivelyโ€”and without thinking, slapped him.

The smack rang out.

Tony froze, stunned. I was stunned too. I hadn’t meant to act, but the slap flew.

"Shit!"

Surprised and furious, Tony’s face turned beet red. He grabbed my wrist and swung at me.

Then the romantic drama clichรฉ happened for real.

Someone grabbed Tony’s hand and yanked. He was thrown hard backward.

I turned, bewildered, and my eyes met Ethan’s.

His eyes, narrow and quiet, had a chill in them that didn’t belong to the Ethan who usually protected and comforted me. He stared Tony up and down, then let out a low chuckle. "A drunk trying to hit a woman?"

After taking hit after hit, Tony felt humiliated. He tried to scramble up to fight back, but Ethan held him down with iron force.

Ethan had been working out for years. Iโ€™d traced each of those eight-pack abs so many times during our nights togetherโ€”every ridge was real.

Outside the plant.

Under the crowdโ€™s watchful eyes, Ethan had taken that slap meant for me and given Tony a piece of his mind.

For a moment, I soaked up every bit of attention.

Iโ€™ve never liked being the center of attention, but when Ethan showed up, I felt an odd little flutter of girlish glee: I wanted to loop my arm through his, parade around the plant with him, and let everyone seeโ€”this is my man, this is how amazing he is.

Childish, but sweet.

The little drama ended with Tony slinking away.

Ethan looked back at me, then turned to face me.

He frowned slightly and murmured, โ€œI just happened to be passing by.โ€

I hooked my arm through his, sweeping the morningโ€™s sourness away in a bright voice. โ€œMm, just happened to be passing by our plant when I got off work.โ€

Ethan rubbed the bridge of his nose and said nothing more.

With everyone staring, I climbed into his car. The black Land Rover was impossible to miss parked at the gate.

I could already imagine the gossip tomorrowโ€”people at Riverside Manufacturing would definitely whisper that I was being kept by him.

But who cared.

What happens today, happens today. Tomorrow can sort itself out.

We rode in silence, the kind of effortless quiet that doesnโ€™t need filling.

We came back to his house in that quiet.

Door closed.

Ethan led me to the sofa and sat down. He tilted his head down, hands folded on the coffee table, fingertips rubbing together.

With what I knew of him, I could tell he was weighing something.

That realization made my chest flutter in a new, anxious way.

Sure enoughโ€”after a long silence, Ethan looked up, thin-lipped and solemn. He spoke the words Iโ€™d been dreading: โ€œMayaโ€ฆwe should stop this. Letโ€™s end it here.โ€

For a heartbeat, my heart seemed to freeze.

I took a slow breath, looked up and smiled at him. โ€œWhy?โ€

Before he could answer, I gripped his hand, palm against the back of his. His skin was cold.

โ€œEthan, I donโ€™t think youโ€™re the kind of jerk who takes what he wants and walks away.โ€

Ethanโ€™s face hardened, as if heโ€™d already decided. He lifted his head slowly. Under the lampโ€™s light I could see the red ring in his eyesโ€”he looked worn out.

I felt a sudden pang of pity.

I leaned closer, against his shoulder, afraid to meet his gaze.

โ€œEthan.โ€

โ€œDonโ€™t end it.โ€ I pressed. โ€œIโ€™ve liked you for years. Can feelings really just stop because you say so?โ€

He didnโ€™t answer. The room felt very still.

I drew in a breath and tightened my fingers around his arm, softening my voice. โ€œIf youโ€™re single, Iโ€™ll stay as your lover, okay? I can keep us secret. I can hide it from my mom. I canโ€”โ€

โ€œMaya.โ€

He cut me off suddenly. He pulled his arm away and straightened me gently, then looked down. โ€œWe already made a mistake. We canโ€™t keep making the same mistake. Iโ€™m fifteen years older than you. Besides feelings, Iโ€™m a friend of your motherโ€”how could weโ€”โ€

โ€œHow could we not?โ€ I wouldnโ€™t relent. I grabbed his hand again, my voice thickening. โ€œYouโ€™re just a friend of my mom. Weโ€™re not married. Why not?โ€

He sighed, reached up and smoothed my hair.

โ€œMaya, youโ€™re youngโ€”you can be naive. I canโ€™t.โ€

โ€œBut we already slept together!โ€

My eyes widened. I didnโ€™t want to force him with tears, but my nose burned and the tears slipped anyway.

Ethan always hated to see me cry.

Over the years, whatever the issue, the moment I cried he almost always gave in.

My mother used to tease him about being a future doting dad.

He bent to wipe my tears, brow knit tight, eyes full of regret and heartacheโ€”those reddened eyes looked exhausted.

I knew then that he truly regretted it.

After wiping my face, Ethan sighed and said, โ€œIโ€™m sorry.โ€

I shook my head. โ€œI volunteered for it.โ€

Then he suddenly crouched and cupped my face, voice husky. โ€œI took your first time and then cowered at taking responsibility. Maya, why was I such a coward?โ€

I fell silent. I didnโ€™t know how to answer. But I also knew Ethan wasnโ€™t a cowardโ€”he was the bravest man Iโ€™d ever seen.

He sighed again.

Then he pressed his hand against the back of my head and gave a gentle pullโ€”I found myself drawn into his arms.

Warm lips landed on mine.

After a featherlight kiss, Ethan cupped my face and said, โ€œIโ€™ll take responsibility.โ€

I froze, then looked up at him, surprised and thrilled. โ€œYou meanโ€”?โ€

He pulled me to his chest. I leaned into him, not seeing his expression.

โ€œTomorrow morning, Iโ€™ll take you to meet your mother.โ€

That night I stayed at Ethanโ€™s again.

I wore his shirt in bed and shared the mattress with him. But this time, nothing happened.

We slept in our clothes, curled up together.

With the lights out, I turned on my side and held him tight.

Everything had moved so fast that I needed reassurance that he really was mine.

Butโ€ฆIโ€™d become clingy and anxious. Even with him beside me, my heart felt oddly empty and untethered.

I worried heโ€™d say he wanted to be together in a rush and then back out. I worried heโ€™d chicken out when faced with my motherโ€™s anger. I worriedโ€”too many worries. When I added them up, they all came down to one fear: that he wouldnโ€™t want me.

Late at night, half asleep, I reached out by reflex and found his side empty.

I jolted awake.

I sat up and scanned the room; only when I saw his silhouette by the window did my heart slow.

He heard the noise and turned. โ€œYou awake?โ€

His voice was calm, but I noticed the cigarette pinched between his fingersโ€”half-smoked.

He rarely smoked in my memory. Except for that time he snagged a cigarette in the hallway, I hadnโ€™t seen him smoke for a year or two.

Ethan stubbed it out and came over to the bed. He picked up the coat draped over a chair and placed it across my shoulders like it was the most natural thing.

I suddenly grabbed his hand. โ€œEthan, I had a nightmare.โ€

He gave a small smile and patted my shoulder. โ€œDreams are opposite things.โ€

I looked up. He was backlit, his face in shadow.

โ€œI dreamed you didnโ€™t want me.โ€

Ethan paused, then patted me again. His voice was soft. โ€œThen that dreamโ€™s oppositeโ€”you probably were the one who left me.โ€

Listening to the exchange, for a moment I felt like we were a real couple.

An ordinary couple in love.

But smelling the tobacco on his shirt, I couldnโ€™t help blurting: โ€œEthan, if I werenโ€™t my momโ€™s daughter, would you fall in love with me?โ€

His fingertips stiffened for a moment.

In the dimness he seemed to purse his lips.

After a long beat, he rubbed my hair and answered quietly, โ€œMaybe.โ€

That little maybe felt shaky. I once read a psychology book that said when someone adds a hesitant word like โ€œmaybeโ€ after a statement, itโ€™s often insincere.

โ€œLetโ€™s eat lunch before you go,โ€ can mean โ€œI donโ€™t want you to stay.โ€
โ€œIโ€™ll pay,โ€ can mean โ€œI donโ€™t want to pay.โ€
โ€œMaybe,โ€ can mean noโ€”or that even he doesnโ€™t know.

โ€œEthanโ€ฆโ€

I called softly, hooked my fingers into his pajama collar.

As a grown manโ€”and an older manโ€”Ethan understood immediately what I was asking.

Under the moonlight he tensed his jaw, reached up to ruffle my hair again, but I ducked away.

I frownedโ€”something I rarely did in front of him. โ€œEthan, that gesture is more like an elder coddling a younger person.โ€

He blinked, ready to respond, but I moved faster. I grabbed his hand and pulled it to my waist.

His hand, cool a moment ago, reacted with sudden heat when it landed at my side.

I leaned forward and breathed warm air in his ear. โ€œThis is the way a man treats a woman.โ€

His breathing deepened. After a momentโ€™s hesitation, he wrapped me in his arms.

A soft sigh came from above. โ€œMaya Lin, what am I to do with you?โ€

He sounded helpless and affectionate at once.

I threw my arms around his neck and collapsed back onto the bed. When he moved to cover me, I knew we were both trapped.

I was wrongโ€”Iโ€™d fallen hopelessly for my motherโ€™s friend, for a man fifteen years older. I let myself be spoiled and kept by him.

But Ethan wasnโ€™t innocent either. Knowing it was wrong, he still kept breaking down each time.

I knew Ethan was attracted to me physically, but I didnโ€™t think he loved me.

That was okay. Iโ€™d wait until the day he did. Life is longโ€”I didnโ€™t believe his heart would stay unmoved forever.

Ethanโ€”time is on our side. Weโ€™ll take it slow.

The next morning he was gone when I woke.

I rose quietly, washed up, dressed.

I trusted Ethan to keep his word. If heโ€™d promised to take responsibility, I was sure he wouldnโ€™t abandon meโ€”at least not before meeting my mother.

And sure enough, when I stepped out of the bedroom, he was at the table.

Today he wore a simple white T-shirt. He stood in the light with a spatula in hand. When he heard me, he turned. โ€œYou up? Come eat.โ€

He spoke gently and poured me a cup of hot milk.

I didnโ€™t answer. Instead I slid my arms around his waist and rested my head against his back, feeling unexpectedly comforted.

โ€œEthan, have you thought it through?โ€ I asked.

By morning he seemed to be in much better spirits. He made me a sandwich and asked softly, "Decided what you want?"

I tightened the hand around his waist without meaning to. "Come with me… to see my mom."

He paused for two seconds, then continued as if nothing had happened.

"Okay," he said, handing me the sandwich he’d made. "Don’t worry. I promised I’d take responsibility."

He reflexively lifted his hand to smooth my hair, but froze halfway up as if remembering something.

He chuckled lightly. "Eat."

I took a bite and then kept replaying the scene in my head.

Luckily, Mom had Uncle Carl around now. If she hadn’t, I might’ve been worried about how she’d take it.

After breakfast Ethan wiped his mouth with a napkin, hesitated for a few seconds, then picked up the phone on the table.

My heart tripped. Under my gaze, he dialed my momโ€”"Hello?"

He took a deep breath when she picked up and spoke calmly. "Can we meet for a bit? Me, you, and Maya."

My mom agreed quickly on the other end. She said littleโ€”just two sentencesโ€”and he hung up.

"Let’s go."

He stared off for a moment, then looked down at me.

For some reason, at that moment it was me who felt shaky. I wasn’t afraid of my mom scolding meโ€”I was terrified that if Ethan was only with me out of a sense of duty, he’d regret it later.

Would he look back and blame me?

As I hesitated, his hand warmed mine.

Ethan’s palm was big, covering my hand completely. "Let’s go. To your place."

I blinked and nodded, getting up to follow him.

We were silent the whole way, neither of us speaking.

At the front door, seeing that familiar threshold, my grip on his hand loosened a little.

I could tell Ethan, who’d seemed so determined, was feeling it too. His palm was slick with sweat and his fingers stiffer than usual.

We stood at the door for a long time without knocking.

I almost chickened out. I tugged his hand, lifted my head to say, "Never mindโ€”"

Then the door openedโ€”my mom was there. We stood in front of her hand in hand, totally unprepared. The three of us stared at each other.

My mom glanced at us, then down at our interlaced fingers.

Silence.

A silence like a grave.

Oddly, the nervousness I felt before knocking gave way to a kind of reckless surrender. I tightened my hold on Ethan, drawing warmth from his palm.

His fingers were stiff, but he did not let go.

Minutes passed. I braced for an explosionโ€”my mom throwing a fit, sobbing hystericallyโ€”but instead she released the doorknob and stepped aside.

"Come in," she said.

She had taken a few minutes to process it, and now her face was calmโ€”so calm I couldn’t read any emotion.

I bit my lip and let Ethan lead me inside.

He just closed the door behind us when a voice came from the kitchen. "The fish is almost done. When will Maya and the girls be back?"

Premium chapters locked

Unlock the rest of the story

200 Book Coins

The next scene of I Loved Him First, Then Left begins with: Uncle Carl poked his head out of the kitchen, stopped when he saw us, then smiledโ€”only his gaze froze on our joined hands…. Continue with the remaining 817 story sections.

Get Book Coins to Unlock