He Begged, I Chose Someone Else

He Begged, I Chose Someone Else cover

He Begged, I Chose Someone Else

But my name isn’t Claire.

Staring at the girl on his phone who looked about fifty percent like me, I finally understood— I was a stand-in.

I smiled and traced the contour of his face with my fingertip.

He didn’t know that he, too, resembled someone else.

01. I met Ethan Walker on the basketball court.

That day I passed the basketball court and saw Ethan Walker playing. On impulse I bought a bottle of water.

Unlike the other girls yelling and cheering, I sat quietly, clutching the bottle, my heart pounding with a secret, dizzying joy.

He moved like the wind. His shooting form was clean and sharp — but that wasn’t what caught me.

On him I saw, somehow, a clumsy boy who couldn’t even play ball.

When he finished and walked past me, he turned his head, paused, and looked at me for a few seconds.

I smiled and held the bottle out. “Here.”

He didn’t refuse. He took it, twisted off the cap, and drank.

I watched him with a small smile, tracing his face with my eyes from his brows to his nose to his mouth, drinking him in greedily.

Then I noticed the angry red scrape on his elbow. It made my eyes sting.

I fumbled him over to the water fountain, washed the wound, patted it dry, and stuck on a bandage.

Still not satisfied, I almost pulled him all the way to the Student Health Center.

My anxious fussing made him laugh.

“Why are you so worried about me? We…don’t even know each other, do we?”

Right — we didn’t.

I pressed my lips shut.

“I’m Ethan Walker. What’s your name?”

“Chloe Reed.”

And that was how we met.

After that, wherever Ethan was, I was there too.

His friends teased him when they saw me. He just smiled and said nothing.

After a lot of stubborn pestering, we were together.

“Let’s be together.”

When he said it, his eyes were sincere, but they looked like they were seeing someone else through me.

I hesitated. It felt unfair to him — I’d approached him with a purpose. Still, I wanted to see him more than from a distance. I wanted to be closer. If this was the way, then fine.

At first, Ethan’s friends looked at him with envy. “Ethan did well — such a pretty girl who’s good to you.”

Now when they looked at me all I saw was pity. Because Ethan wasn’t good to me.

He didn’t like me. He even seemed to dislike me.

So what? I didn’t care. As long as I liked him, that was enough.

I had almost no friends at school and didn’t fit in with my class.

I was at the bottom of the grade rankings.

To avoid failing, I asked the class rep to help me study. He agreed readily.

Not only because he was smart and kind, but because of his voice.

Daniel Hayes had a beautiful voice — clear and gentle.

I stared at his lips moving and, before I knew it, blurted, “Can you…call me ‘Chlo-Chlo’?”

He froze, his pen pausing.

I repeated it. He said, “Okay.”

His face flushed as he said, carefully, “Chlo-Chlo.”

It wasn’t — not the right feeling, not the right tone.

My eyes filled; I turned my face to the corner of the desk and said nothing.

No one could be him…no one…

“You okay?”

He looked flustered and fished for a tissue.

“Nothing. I’m going to wash my face.”

The faucet gushed. My tears finally spilled. I missed you so much, Jason Moore.

Freshman summer was blistering; Jason was irresistible.

“Jase, I don’t get this problem. Help me,” I poked Jason’s arm with my pen.

“Not now.” He didn’t even look up, buried in his book.

“Please, Jase, help me. It’s hard—”

He glanced at me and shifted slightly.

His voice was so pleasing — a low, husky softness tinged with an inexplicable charm.

I watched him and didn’t hear the words. He set his pen down with a small sigh. “Do you want to fail?”

I felt guilty. “I’m paying attention.”

I muttered, “It’s your fault for being too good-looking.”

Jason laughed, then tapped the pen on my head.

“Ow, ow — that hurts!”

I clutched my skull and feigned pain. He believed my lousy acting, puckered up, and leaned in.

I kissed him suddenly — misjudged the angle and hit his teeth.

Jason pressed his hand to his mouth, embarrassed and angry. “You—”

Red-faced, I mumbled, awkwardly, “Your mouth’s so soft. My tooth hurt.”

No one said anything for a few breaths. I didn’t know if he’d heard me.

Unable to focus on my book, I peeked sideways and saw Jason’s face flushed to his neck. I lay my head on the desk and smiled — grinning wider than a summer day.

“Don’t smile!”

He snapped through his teeth.

Pulling myself out of that memory left me exhausted.

02. Passing the stairwell, I saw Ethan pressed against a wall, kissing a girl in the corner.

I could even hear them. I watched until the girl opened her eyes and screamed when she saw me, then Ethan turned.

He looked surprised, brows knitting — like I’d interrupted something.

He leaned down and whispered something to the girl. She smiled, kissed him once, and shot me a mocking look.

She left. I stayed frozen while Ethan climbed the stairs.

“Are you crying?”

He was leaning on the railing, just level with me. The corner of his mouth curled with a teasing smile. “Jealous?”

Should I be?

“No.”

He didn’t like that answer. He frowned and stared at me for a long time, then let out a short self-mocking smile. “Right, why would you be jealous? I want wontons from Waverly Noodles.”

I paused, then said okay.

Waverly Noodles was by the school gate, a bit far. I practically ran and arrived exhausted fifteen minutes later.

Ethan and his friends were playing cards, and there was a girl sitting with them. They saw me and smirked under their breath, “She’s so obedient.”

Ethan frowned. “Took you that long to buy something?”

My cheeks were red, hair sticking to my face with sweat. I set the food down and turned to leave.

He called after me. “Give me your portion.”

He pointed to the cold noodles in my hands.

I pressed my cracked lips together and put them down in front of him.

Ethan pushed them toward the girl. “Eat.”

“This isn’t right.” She tittered and glanced at me, then cheerfully tore it open and started eating.

I watched without a ripple, exhausted and beat from running.

Suddenly Ethan’s face changed. He flicked his hand. I didn’t react fast enough: the container hit my leg, boiling broth splashed down, and my thigh flamed red.

Patrons gasped and looked our way.

Ethan’s friends and that girl snickered at my mess.

“I told you I hate scallions! How many times do I have to say it?”

Ethan’s voice was controlled fury; his eyes were full of disgust.

I looked down at the wontons scattered on the floor. Tears pricked my eyes — maybe from the burn, maybe not.

I know you don’t like scallions, but Jason does. I wanted you to be Jason, but you’re not. Your tastes are different. Everything about you is different.

All of this should’ve been obvious.

“You okay, sweetheart?” Mr. Barnes hurried over.

I shook my head, grabbed a broom, swept the mess, then managed a soft “I’m sorry” to Ethan before turning away.

As I walked, the tears came uncontrolled.

I still couldn’t accept it. Everything reminded me that Jason was gone and no one, no matter how much they resembled him, could replace him.

I noticed Ethan because his brows and eyes mirrored Jason’s.

At first he was okay with me, even smiling sometimes. Then he changed. It seemed like everything I did was wrong.

I tried to make him smile, but my efforts were a joke to him.

Ridiculous. Other people would’ve broken up ages ago; I clung on like a desperate fool.

But fine — I brought this on myself. Even if he was mean and people whispered that I was pathetic, I didn’t care. Inside I was steady as stone. I just wanted him to smile. Once. Just once.

Ethan had many admirers at school. Since I’d hooked his attention, I owed a price.

I’d just left Harrison Library when a group of girls blocked me on Willow Bridge.

They probably thought I was easy to bully. They grabbed what I was carrying. I reached to snatch it back.

One girl raised her hand high. She was one who always chased Ethan, though he never looked her way. So she took it out on me.

“You’re unbelievable. He treats you like garbage and you still won’t break up,” she said, tall and haughty. I had to look up at her; the sun hurt my eyes.

I smiled and squinted. “Even if we broke up, that wouldn’t be your business. Do you really think Ethan would like you? Get some self-awareness — he’s with me. And move.”

She took a breath, tamped down her anger, and tossed my things into the lake, then motioned to her friends: “Pull her over.”

My fists clenched. I glared, then slapped her hard. There was a chorus of shocked gasps. Without hesitation I dove into the water.

“Holy—she jumped in!”

“Is she crazy? For a few books…”

“What if she drowns? It’s deep.”

The water was murky. I couldn’t open my eyes and held my breath while I felt around: rocks, glass bottles, weeds, books — everything but what I wanted.

Panic and urgency churned inside. I lost track of time until I couldn’t hold my breath and surfaced.

A voice yelled from the shore. A figure moved.

“Chloe!”

It was Ethan.

“Get out here, Chloe! Are you trying to kill yourself?”

I ignored him and sank back into the water, searching some more.

Less than two minutes later, someone grabbed my arm and hauled me up.

I had no strength to struggle; I let them pull me, water streaming into my mouth and nose.

Once I was on shore, a coat was wrapped around me.

“My—my things…”

I spat out a mouthful of water and opened my eyes. Under a ring of harsh light I saw a blurry, familiar profile.

Jason Moore…

A rush of hurt swelled from my chest and tears fell like beads with the sound choked from my throat. My voice came out rough. “They… they threw away the little toy you gave me…”

“You’d risk your life over a toy?!”

The hand clutching his jacket froze… that wasn’t his voice.

I wiped my tears with my other hand and realized who was holding me—Ethan Walker.

He was staring at me, furious. His stare was sharp, his hair plastered to his head, water droplets tracing down his jaw.

Summoning what little strength I had, I shoved him away.

While he stood there stunned, I got to my feet, tightened the coat around me, and walked out of the crowd.

For a moment I’d mistaken Ethan for Jason.

He called after me; I ignored him and walked faster.

That night I sat alone by the lake, watching the glittering surface.

I couldn’t find it… I’d never find it again… I rubbed my stinging eyes, my chest tight, overwhelmed by a helpless, heavy sadness.

Sorry, Jason…I can never keep your things safe.

My nails dug into the dirt; grief and gloom crowded me without release.

The wind off the lake was strong, stirring ripples and making my eyes dry.

I must have been there for a long time because I started to feel dizzy and chilled. I pushed up on my knees and stood.

My legs were numb from sitting; I slipped and suddenly pitched forward.

Just as I was about to fall into the water, an arm wrapped tight around me and lifted me up.

“Chloe, are you out of your mind? Going to do something reckless in the middle of the night? Do you want to die?”

Standing in the moonlight, I saw Ethan’s face drawn tight, his eyes wide.

“If I hadn’t grabbed you, would you have jumped?”

I opened my mouth to say something but didn’t know what to say.

You’ve got it wrong — how could I ever be that desperate?

I lowered my head and whispered, “No.”

“For a few books?” he scoffed. “I’ll get you new ones tomorrow. Tell me how many. Don’t act like you’re going to die over something so small.”

I cut him off, clenching my fists. Trying to keep my face steady, I said coldly, “What do you know?”

You know nothing!

Then I tore my arm free from his grip, pushed through the pain in my feet, and walked away without looking back.

03. That night I was so thirsty I could barely stand it.

I stumbled up half-asleep, groped for a glass, drank, then crawled back under the covers. I tossed and turned for hours, unable to fall asleep.

My head was spinning.

I picked up my phone: 2:30 a.m.

My finger accidentally tapped dial and a number I knew by heart flashed on the screen, stabbing at my eyes.

I knew it wouldn’t connect, but I dialed anyway.

A cold automated voice answered: “The number you have dialed is not in service.”

I kept redialing, stubborn, until tears slid down into my hair.

I buried my face in the pillow and cried silently.

When Jason and I first got close, I always found excuses to make him do my homework.

“Jason, I’m not feeling well,” I’d push my notebook toward him, “my hands are weak—take notes for me.”

He’d look at me like he had no choice but to oblige.

“Why are you so nice?” I’d rest my head on the desk and look up at him. “You’re handsome and you’re so good to me—how are you so good?”

Jason would curl the corner of his mouth. “Brown-noser.”

“Ugh, my head hurts—can you rub it?”

I’d tug on his sleeve. He’d lift a hand without a word.

Warm fingertips would press to my temple, the pressure just right.

I’d squint at him. The soft light through the window made him glow somehow.

My gaze dropped to his slightly parted lips and I thought if I weren’t sick, I’d kiss him again.

Somehow I fell asleep.

When I woke, Jason was watching me, smiling, his jacket draped over me. He looked away quickly when I opened my eyes.

“It’s almost dark and everyone’s gone. Why didn’t you call me?” my voice was nasal.

My things were packed.

We walked back to the dorm side by side. Jason was much taller than me.

I noticed he kept glancing my way.

“Why do you keep looking at me?” I snapped.

His face softened into a smile, eyes crinkling. I stood there a few seconds, then smiled back for no reason.

If I’d known then what Jason had done to my face, I would have socked him on the spot.

When I washed my face and lifted my bangs, two thick dark eyebrows stared back at me from the mirror. I was shocked and annoyed.

So that’s why Jason looked awkward—he felt guilty because he’d done something mischievous.

He was so dead meat!

The next morning, ready to confront him, I saw cold medicine on the desk and Jason quietly writing beside it; my anger dissolved.

The dream had been so real.

I woke up at 7:30, hurried through my routine, and walked into class to the bell.

I saw Ethan in the back row waving at me. I was surprised—and noticed books and breakfast on my desk.

He pointed and said, “For you.”

“Thanks.”

My voice was hoarse.

He noticed and asked, “Are you sick?”

“Yeah.”

Ethan didn’t say more and left. Watching him go, I couldn’t understand him—he’d never been this gentle, never brought me breakfast. Usually I was the one standing at his door waiting with food.

During break he came back with cold medicine.

“Why aren’t you taking it?” he asked, looking at the food.

“Not hungry yet.”

“Eat the breakfast first, then take the medicine.”

“Okay, thanks.”

Maybe my distant attitude that day made him uneasy; he kept glancing my way.

“Come have lunch with me,” he said.

I hesitated, then nodded.

At lunch Ethan ordered a lot of dishes—all things I didn’t like. Mid-meal his phone rang; he frowned and sounded annoyed. I could hear a woman’s voice on the other end. I guessed a girl was sulking and he was calming her.

Sure enough, after he hung up he told me to take my time eating and left.

I lost my appetite and put down my chopsticks once he walked out.

04. I didn’t understand why Ethan’s attitude had flipped 180 degrees, but his behavior afterward made me wonder if he’d become a different person.

He started joining me for meals, walking me back to the dorm, standing up for me in front of his friends, even bringing me milk tea, clothes, and bags.

His sudden kindness caught me off guard.

Honestly, I’d rather he be the old Ethan—bossy and indifferent—so I could feel safe being my old self.

I tied my hair in a messy bun and tugged at the white puff-sleeve dress he’d bought for me. Ethan’s gifts were mostly white, and I didn’t like white.

This outfit was his preference.

Ethan was already waiting downstairs. When he saw me, he froze.

He snapped back to himself as I walked up and smiled. “Let’s go.”

He reached for my hand and I instinctively pulled away. “I’m still not used to this,” I said.

Ethan quickly recovered and smiled. “I’ll take you somewhere.”

But we never made it—he got a call in the middle of the walk. He looked anxious, then spoke in a surprisingly gentle voice: “Wait for me there, don’t go anywhere…I’ll be there soon.”

He left without hesitation, forgetting me. I’d never seen him rush like that and felt a little curious.

I didn’t overthink it and went to the arcade nearby, played for two hours, and came out after dark.

On my way back to campus I ran into Ethan and another girl.

I stood by the road waiting for a bus and watched Ethan carefully help her into a cab. It was too dark to see her face clearly, but she seemed drunk.

The taxi passed by me and, through the window, I saw Ethan holding her close, tender in a way I’d never seen.

Back at school, he called and asked where I was. I gripped my phone and after a moment told him my location.

“Wait for me,” he said.

After about ten minutes Ethan arrived with a milk tea. “Sorry, I said I’d take you out but something came up.”

“It’s okay,” I lied, and smiled understandingly while hiding my skewer of barbecue behind my back.

We looked at each other for a beat before he awkwardly looked away. His gaze landed on my skirt. “What’s that?”

I followed his eyes and saw a conspicuous white stain—grease from the barbecue had dripped there. Ethan frowned.

See? White gets dirty so easily. I really shouldn’t wear white.

He shifted his gaze to my loose hair and I could feel that he was in a bad mood.

After that night Ethan seemed to vanish—he didn’t seek me out and I didn’t reach out to him either.

From one of his friends I learned he had a childhood friend he liked. I guessed it was the drunk girl from that night.

I thought about it a long time. If he already liked someone else, he didn’t like me; I shouldn’t hold him back. After all, I only got close because of Jason. Even if I looked like someone else—what did it matter?

I was just lying to myself. If he didn’t love me, no one could replace him.

Although I didn’t know why Ethan had been with me while liking someone else, I decided I couldn’t keep accepting his kindness while feeling guilty and uneasy.

I wrote a breakup message to him, edited it carefully, and sent it.

When it went through I felt like I’d been released.

Knowing Ethan, he’d probably scold me first before agreeing. Given how strange he’d been lately, I didn’t know how he would react.

But my message got no reply for days—as if it had sunk with a stone.

Waiting for the bus at the school gate, I saw Ethan after a long time. He’d just gotten out of a taxi and looked exhausted.

I called out, “Ethan.”

He paused. “What are you doing here?”

“I want to talk to you.”

He ran a hand through his hair, irritation flickering across his face. "Fine."

"Did you see the message I sent you?"

He narrowed his eyes, as if thinking. "I thought you were just being moody."

So in his eyes, I was the same as those girls who orbited him and threw little tantrums now and then.

I took a deep breath and forced myself to be serious. "Okay. I’m saying this officially, Ethan — we’re breaking up."

Only then did Ethan lift his lids, smiling with that half-smirk. "Because I ignored you these past few days? Chloe, can’t you be more reasonable? I really—"

"No."

I cut him off.

It wasn’t for that. I didn’t want to break up because I’d feel guilty about using him.

"Because of Lily?"

Lily was the class rep in my class. There was no way Ethan would be so ridiculous as to think I wanted to break up because of him.

"None of that. I’m serious."

Ethan was silent for a moment; a complicated look passed through his eyes.

He said, "Fine, do as you wish."

Then he brushed past me.

On his face was the certainty of a winner, like he was sure I’d come crawling back in a few days, bawling for a second chance.

But I didn’t. No need to deal with Ethan, no need to look at that face. I lived the two-point life of dorm and Harrison Library — productive, but with a hollow heart.

Every so often my thoughts drifted to Jason — everything about him.

05. Ever since Jason was gone, I dared not touch anything related to him, not even his family.

But today, at Maple Café, I ran into Laura.

Jason’s sister.

I hadn’t seen her in ages, not since the Moores moved away.

"Chloe."

Laura called me over.

I stood there with my coffee, at a loss.

She glanced at the seat across and motioned for me to sit.

She asked about how I’d been; I answered, and most of the time she talked.

Suddenly Laura’s phone vibrated. She glanced at me and answered.

I held my breath and moved as quietly as possible.

A gentle voice came through the receiver. I froze, my heart stuttering, breath held.

That voice… "Don’t come over. Wait for me there."

Laura hung up quickly.

"Sis, is it—"

My voice trembled despite my effort.

Laura sighed and shook her head. "Chloe, forget him."

I gripped my cup so tight my knuckles hurt and managed a crooked smile. "Who are you talking about?"

Laura was silent a long moment, then turned her head to look out the floor-to-ceiling window. "Other than Jason, what topics do we even have in common?"

"Sis, can you tell me… where is Jason’s grave?"

I lowered my eyes and stared at the latte art. "There are so many things I want to tell him."

Laura said nothing.

"Sis, why won’t you tell me? Do you still hate me?"

Laura didn’t deny it. She frowned at her watch. "I have to go. I’m sorry."

Sister, what are you avoiding? What are you hiding?

I put on an obedient smile. "Okay. Bye, then."

As she left, Laura said, "I know you can’t accept it, but it’s over. We have to move forward. I don’t think Jason would want you to be like this."

Outside the window dusk had fallen and her figure stretched long. She hurried away.

Hearing that voice identical to Jason’s had frozen my blood.

I couldn’t accept that he was gone. But if he were alive, why wouldn’t he contact me? Could he really abandon me?

I followed Laura, keeping my distance.

A red light held me on the curb and traffic surged between us. Laura crossed and turned left.

Through the crowd and cars I saw her link arms with a man.

Tall, broad-shouldered, his gestures and bearing familiar. Even from a distance I knew — that was Jason.

It had to be him. It had to!

They were about to disappear from sight and I bolted forward.

One step out and someone yanked me back. Off balance, I fell onto the pavement.

"Child, did you hurt yourself?" A woman helped me up. "It’s still a red light. What are you rushing for?"

"I’m fine."

My voice sounded hoarse. I looked up and saw they were already gone.

"Oh my, why are you crying?"

"I—"

I wiped my face; my palm came away wet.

Maybe she sensed I wasn’t all right. Her face filled with worry. "Look at the traffic, dear. If something happens, your parents will worry."

"I’m okay, thank you."

I forced a smile though tears streamed down. I must have looked a mess.

The walk back to campus felt endless and hollow.

I flipped through my contacts and stopped at a name.

Daniel Hayes — Laura’s ex.

Sister, why did you lie to me? Why?

Daniel didn’t know where the Moores had moved. He only knew Laura’s work address in the neighboring town.

I took a leave, went overnight to that town, and waited outside her office from dawn until the neon lit the night. Watching people come and go, none of them Jason. My hope faded into numb despair.

I rubbed my dry lips and my sore legs, looked up at the night sky. The stars blinked faintly; the cool breeze soothed me little by little.

Then a tall figure appeared at the building entrance and the spark I had buried flared anew.

Laura got into a cab.

I hailed one after her. "Driver, follow that car."

The taxi pulled into a residential complex.

The elevator number stopped at 28 and I took the other elevator up.

I sat in a dim stairwell, unsure which door was hers.

When I was about to come back the next morning, the door to 2802 opened… and a slender hand reached out. A mole at the base of the thumb was obvious. A peach-wood bracelet was tied to the wrist.

I jumped up; my heart thudded. If I wasn’t imagining things, Jason had a mole at the base of his left thumb and wore that peach-wood bracelet — the one I’d given him.

Before I could move forward, the hand set down a trash bag and the door shut.

I suppressed the wild joy and leaned close to the wall, trying to hear anything inside. But there was nothing.

I stood there a long time before leaving.

The wind on my face carried some of my exhaustion away. My steps grew lively and I smiled without meaning to.

Jason — I’ll see you tomorrow.

06. The next morning I woke early and only went once I was sure Laura had left for work.

I still didn’t know why Laura had lied or hidden things, but I knew she didn’t want me to see Jason.

Premium chapters locked

Unlock the rest of the story

200 Book Coins

The next scene of He Begged, I Chose Someone Else begins with: Standing before the closed door, I lifted my hand several times and then put it down…. Continue with the remaining 771 story sections.

Get Book Coins to Unlock