The Moment I Stopped Loving Him

The Moment I Stopped Loving Him cover

The Moment I Stopped Loving Him

I had a secret crush on the campus heartthrob, and he knew itโ€”knew it perfectly well.

When he and other girls went to the movies, he’d invite me along.

When they went on late-night dates, he’d ring me up to run things over to the Riverside Inn.

People mocked me as a simp, but I stayed willingly devoted, doing my part without complaint.

Then one day, all at once, I stopped liking him.

Evan Carter, the bad-boy campus heartthrob at Waverly University, liked senior Claire Bennett.

Heโ€™d once chased her with all he had, dramatically and loudlyโ€”but sheโ€™d turned him down without blinking.

After Claire graduated, Evanโ€™s private life went off the rails.

One day heโ€™d be with one girl, the next day wrapped around someone else.

But without fail, they all looked a little like Claire.

In Evanโ€™s sophomore year, a girl started trailing him everywhereโ€”Maya Ellis.

Everyone noticed her, not just because she resembled Claire, but because she was the one who stayed by Evanโ€™s side the longest.

When people talked about her, the verdict was unanimous: How can someone be such a simp?

That girl they called a simp was me.

(1)
โ€œMaya, I want a Coke.โ€

โ€œOkay.โ€

I nodded.

As I was getting up, he said again, โ€œShe wants one too.โ€

I looked over and saw him pointing at the girl he had been holding in his arms.

โ€œGot it.โ€

I turned and hadnโ€™t taken two steps before a chorus of snickers and chatter rose behind me.

โ€œNo wayโ€”sheโ€™s that obedient?โ€

โ€œEvan, what did you give her? Some kind of love potion?โ€

โ€œDude, Evan, youโ€™re my hero.โ€

I paused, then steadily walked away from those voices.

A little while later I went back to the basketball court.

Evan had just stopped. I handed him two sodas. He didnโ€™t say anythingโ€”took them, turned, and gave one to the girl heโ€™d been carrying.

All the boys around watched me with pitying looks.

I was used to those glances. I sat back down and kept watching them play.

The sun slanted lower, and when they were getting ready to leave, I packed my things and followed at a distance.

โ€œMaya.โ€

Evan called me.

I already knew what he wanted. I dug a lollipop out of my bag and gave it to him.

At the fork in the road we split up.

I hadnโ€™t gone far when I looked back.

Evan unwrapped the candy, touched it to the girlโ€™s lips, then leaned down and kissed her. The boys around them hooted and teased.

I saw Evan glance my wayโ€”his mouth curved upโ€”and then he deepened the kiss.

After the kiss, he wrapped an arm around her and they walked on.

I watched them turn the corner and disappear, then headed back to the dorm.

(2)
โ€œHello?โ€

I was reading when my phone buzzed. The screen said Evan Carter, so I answered.

โ€œMaya, Li Xue and I booked a room but we forgot it. Can you go buy one for me?โ€

I blinked and checked the time. It was already 9:40 p.m. โ€œNow?โ€

โ€œIf itโ€™s inconvenient, forget it.โ€

He made as if to hang up.

โ€œWhere are you?โ€

I asked.

โ€œRiverside Inn, Room 5025.โ€

โ€œGot it.โ€

I put on my shoes to go when my childhood friend and roommate Lily Grant stopped me. โ€œMouse.โ€

โ€œWhatโ€™s up?โ€

She opened her mouth, closed it, opened again, sighed, and finally said, โ€œIโ€™ll go with you.โ€

She threw on a jacket and came with me.

Thereโ€™s a convenience store downstairs from the Riverside Inn. I bought a pack of what he wanted, then Lily and I went up to the fifth floor. We knocked on 5025.

Evan opened the door after a moment, looking impatient. Heโ€™d already taken off his jacket. He took the pack from my hand and shut the door without saying a word.

โ€œYou bastard!โ€ Lily pretended to bang on the door and promised to teach him a lesson.

I grabbed her wrist. โ€œLetโ€™s go.โ€

She stopped and came away with me.

We waited outside by the curb. I sat on a stone block while Lily stood in front of me, worried. โ€œMouse, you knowโ€”โ€

โ€œLils, forget it.โ€

I cut her off. She stopped and sighed, then patted my head.

(3)
Evanโ€™s friend Mark Davis started dating my roommate Zoe Lin, and one weekend they invited a crew out to a karaoke bar. Zoe asked if Iโ€™d go with her since sheโ€™d be the only girl in the group, and I said yes.

When Mark pulled up to pick up Zoe, he seemed surprised to see me, then gave a friendly smile.

I rode in the front seat and let the couple sit in back.

At the KTV a crowd had already gathered by the entrance. Evan stood outโ€”tall, handsomeโ€”the kind of person you noticed first in a group.

People laughed and pointed when they saw me walk in. I caught snippets: โ€œShe even came along for this? Thatโ€™s so thirsty.โ€

Zoe tugged my hand, full of regret. I patted her to say it was fine.

We went into a private room. Zoe sat next to Mark. I took a seat at the edge. Someone offered me a drink; I declined.

The mood was light, everyone joking and singing. Occasionally someone attempted a high note and the group burst into laughter.

I watched Evan in the center. His hair fell low over his eyes; heโ€™d been drinking and looked tipsy, a little lost. There was a small mole on the right side of his nose. The dim blue light made him look like someone else I knew.

He was looking more and more like that personโ€ฆ

(4)
Afterward everyone drifted off in different directions.

Evan was clearly drunk, stumbling and swaying, leaning on the guys trying to help him. I followed them and saw Evan bump into a wall for the third time, a red mark rising on his forehead. I hurried over and said to the guy supporting him, โ€œIโ€™ll take him.โ€

โ€œUhโ€”sure.โ€

The guy handed Evan over to me. The others all looked like they understood and left the rest to us.

Carefully, another guy and I supported Evan as we got outside. The friends were haggling with a taxi driver; it wasnโ€™t going well. The other guy went to help with the driver, leaving me holding Evanโ€™s weight.

He put most of his weight on me, and I barely held my ground.

I looked up at him. His medium-length hair hid his sharp brows and features, making him look soft in that moment. The bruise on his forehead stood outโ€”probably from when he hit the wall.

I stared for a moment, then reached up and stroked the swollen spot and the little mole beside his nose.

A cold breeze snapped me awake. I looked at Evan and forced a bitter smile.

They finally got three taxis. Evan and his friends went to a hotel. Zoe, Mark, and I went back to campus.

I handed Evan to his friends and climbed into a car.

I opened the window and rested my hand on the sill, watching the city blur past. Behind me, Mark and Zoe laughed and teased each other.

The cold wind touched me, but it couldnโ€™t clear my head.

Daniel Stoneโ€”I miss you so muchโ€ฆ

(5)
I lived the โ€œsimpโ€ life everyone mocked. Before I knew it, I was already a junior. As Evanโ€™s reputation grew, so did mine.

Time slipped by.

May Day came, and Lily and I packed up to go home to Hillside. Dad picked us up at the station and my parents took us back. Our house is only three meters from Lilyโ€™sโ€”neighbors since childhood.

Dad declined my friendโ€™s parentsโ€™ offer to go out to dinner, saying weโ€™d eat at home. Opening the front door, I was hit by that familiar โ€œhomeโ€ smell.

That afternoon Dad went fishing with a friend while I watered plants on the balcony with Mom. She loves gardening and had a balcony full of different flowers.

We chatted while I watered; she suddenly brought up my wasted high school years and mentioned Mr. Stone.

โ€œCome to think of it, thank goodness for Mr. Stone. I wonder where he is nowโ€ฆโ€

She sighed.

I froze in place, watering in a daze, thoughts flying across the Atlantic.

โ€œMy plants!โ€ Mom snapped, snatching the watering can from my hand. Iโ€™d overwatered some new flowers and their leaves had drooped.

โ€œGo, go, go,โ€ she scolded, sending me off the balcony.

I lay on my bed and stared at the ceiling for a long timeโ€ฆ

(6)
When the holiday ended, I went back to school.

Evan, unusually, came up to me and asked if I wanted to see a movie. I hesitated, then agreed.

On Saturday I realized I wasnโ€™t the only one heโ€™d invited.

He had his arm around a girl I didnโ€™t know and handed me a ticket. They were sitting together in the row in front of mine, at the far end; I sat behind them.

When the lights went down the movie started. I heard the couple in front of me whispering and kissingโ€”the little โ€œtsk tskโ€ soundsโ€”and because Evan was diagonally in front of me, I even saw his hand slip under the girlโ€™s jacket.

I sighed and looked up at the screen.

The film was a romance anthologyโ€”some stories touching, some so-so. I watched a story about an older woman and a younger man end, then a new one began.

It was about a teacher-student romance: the girl liked the man, he liked her back, but because of the teacher-student taboo their relationship was tangled and fraught.

The ending jumped six years forward. In an empty classroom, a bespectacled man graded papers at the lectern.

โ€œTeacher.โ€

The camera cut to the door and a well-dressed woman came in, standing beside him.

โ€œWhat is it?โ€

He asked with a soft smile.

โ€œI like you.โ€

She wrapped him in an embrace.

โ€œI like you too.โ€

He hugged her back.

The scene ended and rolled on to the next story.

But I couldnโ€™t shake the image.

I thought of one person: medium-length hair, thin glasses, white shirt, blue pants. When you got close, you could smell a faint scent of herbal medicine.

(7)
On the walk back, I trailed behind the two of them, my mind foggy.

โ€œOw.โ€

I glanced up. Evan had fallen and the girl moved to help him up.

I watched them like I was on autopilot until Evan looked up and I saw a cut on his brow, blood streaming down. I finally snapped out of it.

I went over and, with the girlโ€™s help, lifted him. My heart started pounding for no reason.

โ€œLetโ€™s go backโ€”just a small cut.โ€

โ€œNo.โ€

For the first time, I contradicted him. I looked up at Evan and he looked back at me.

After a moment he averted his eyes and said, โ€œMm.โ€

We went to a nearby clinic. I hadnโ€™t expected such a small wound to need stitches.

When I saw Evan again, I realized my panic hadnโ€™t been baseless.

There was a three-centimeter scar above his eyebrow that made him look harsherโ€”like an edge had been filed into him.

He was very different from the person in my memory… โ€œHeโ€™s not really Daniel Stone.โ€

Those words looped in my head.

โ€œArenโ€™t you leaving?โ€

Evan looked at me impatiently.

โ€œHuh?

Yeah.โ€

For the first time, I turned and walked away without any lingering.

I walked a few steps, then started running.

I ran for so long my legs finally gave out and I had to stop.

I found myself on a bridge with people passing every way. The summer breeze was cool and pleasant. I leaned on the railing and realized something.

No one will ever be exactly like Daniel Stone.

I buried my face in my arms and couldnโ€™t even tell how I felt.

After a while my phone rang. I opened itโ€”Lily calling. I answered, โ€œHello.โ€

โ€œHello?

Oh my god, Mouse, you scared me to death. I was walking on the field and saw Evan come back. I waited and waited for you to come backโ€”thought youโ€™d been kidnapped.โ€

โ€œIโ€™ll head back soon.โ€

โ€œWhere the hell are you now?โ€

โ€œUh… at Maple Bridge. Why?โ€

I checked the map and read the bridge name.

โ€œWait for me. Iโ€™m not far. I swear Iโ€™m afraid something happened to youโ€”I came out in flip-flops to find you.โ€

โ€œOkay.โ€

Her words made me smile. I turned and saw someone on the other side of the bridge.

For a second I couldnโ€™t tell if it was real or a mirage.

He was in a white shirt and blue pantsโ€”no difference from the person in my memory.

He walked toward the end of the bridge; I ran toward that end too.

I donโ€™t know where the strength came fromโ€”my legs had been numb moments ago but now I chased him as fast as I could.

At the bridgehead a group of middle-aged women in pink shirts appeared, each with a fan in hand. He slipped into the crowd and my heart raced. I blurted, โ€œDanโ€”โ€

The syllable barely left my lips when he seemed to sense it and turned to look at me.

He wore his thin wire-frame glasses, his brows gentle, a high nose with a small beauty mark at the sideโ€”and he gave me a faint smile.

That familiar smile nearly made me cry.

โ€œMouse!โ€

Lilyโ€™s voice came from behind. I turned: she was trudging over in her flip-flops.

โ€œLils!

Iโ€”โ€

I waved at her and pointed to where Daniel had been, but he was gone.

โ€œWhatโ€™s wrong?โ€

โ€œIโ€”I just saw Daniel Stone.โ€

I wanted to follow him, but Lily grabbed my arm.

โ€œLetโ€™s go back first.โ€

โ€œI, I reallyโ€”โ€

I stopped mid-sentence.

Suddenly I wondered: was it just my imagination?

When I was sixteen I was in tenth grade.

Because my foundations were weak and I loved reading Mary-Sue romance novels, my grades tanked. I was always near the bottom of the class.

My dad thought that couldnโ€™t continue. The family had made a bit of money from business, so he hired a tutor for me.

Could I agree? Of course not.

School life was exhausting enoughโ€”having a tutor would steal my free time.

So I ran, hid, and even climbed out windows.

One sunny afternoon my dad dragged me home by the ear, and I still had an unopened copy of The Domineering Prince and the Ice Princess tucked under my arm.

That day I met Daniel Stone for the first time.

He sat on the sofa in a floral shirt and black pants, holding the tea my mom had brewed. He smiled gently at me.

But I was in my rebellious phase, steeped in Mary-Sue fantasiesโ€”my type was the domineering, handsome guy who pins you to the wall and says, โ€œWoman, you canโ€™t escape me.โ€ I looked down my nose at the Daniel Stone type.

โ€œPfft.โ€

I forgot my ear was still in my dadโ€™s hand. As soon as I scoffed, his grip tightened and I nearly begged for mercy.

โ€œOw ow ow! Dad, daddy, ease upโ€”โ€

โ€œSorry to make you a laughingstock, Mr. Stone.โ€

My dad let go and went to talk to him.

Daniel stood up, bowed slightly, and shook my fatherโ€™s hand.

โ€œCome here!โ€

My dad glared at me fiercely, then turned to smile at Daniel. I learned then how fast my dad could change faces.

Reluctantly I went forward. โ€œPlease take care of her, Mr. Stone.โ€

โ€œPlease take care of her as well,โ€ Daniel replied with a smile.

Sunlight fell through the window on his face; he and the light were both unbearably gentle.

Daniel was my dadโ€™s recommendation. He tutored me every Saturday and Sunday from ten to three. During that time I tried one last gentle conversation with my mom.

โ€œDaniel just graduated collegeโ€”heโ€™s young and very knowledgeable. What else do you want to say?โ€

โ€œMom, Iโ€™m not studying for myself. Iโ€™m doing it for you guys.โ€

โ€œOh?โ€

She glanced at me and said, โ€œTell me more.โ€

โ€œIโ€™m doing it for the family. Mr. Stoneโ€™s tutoring fee must be expensiveโ€”if I donโ€™t take lessons, the family saves a lot, right?โ€

โ€œLily,โ€ she said, โ€œI need to discuss this with my eighteen-year-old boyfriend.โ€

โ€œHuh? Where did you find an eighteen-year-old boyfriend? Would dad agree?โ€

I was bewildered.

โ€œI donโ€™t have one, so itโ€™s not up for discussion.โ€

She stood, left the room, and floated back a final line: โ€œKeep it up and Iโ€™ll cut your allowance.โ€

She left me standing in a daze.

And so my tutoring days began.

On his first day Daniel asked a few basic questions. I started off confident, but the more questions he asked the more shaky I became.

If it had been Lily sheโ€™d be poking my forehead and calling me dumb.

But Daniel said nothing. He quickly wrote notes, slid them over, and told me exactly how to do the problems when I frowned.

I suspected he read minds.

Not that I minded.

With his help my grades improved a lot. My parents were thrilledโ€”so enthusiastic it was like they were hosting a visiting official.

โ€œMouse, pour Mr. Stone a cup of water.โ€

โ€œMouse, bring Mr. Stone an apple.โ€

โ€œMouse, the bread I boughtโ€”give some to Mr. Stone.โ€

I watched the bread I didnโ€™t get to eat and wondered: who am I? Where am I?

Daniel must be their son.

I carried the bread into the room.

Young crushes can be a single, fleeting moment.

Like when Daniel looked up at the sound in the doorway, smiled gently, and said, โ€œHome?โ€

โ€œHuh?

Oh… yeah.โ€

I lowered my head, flustered, feeling my heart race.

โ€œWhy?!โ€

I slammed my head on the desk in impotent fury.

โ€œYou asking me?โ€

Lily glared at me over her popsicle.

โ€œSigh…โ€

I sighed. โ€œI just canโ€™t figure it out. I see him every dayโ€”I should be used to him. So why do I suddenly feel my heart skip at random moments?โ€

โ€œWho knows. Maybe youth.โ€

Lily asked, โ€œWhat are you going to do about it? Tell Mom you have a crush and get him fired?โ€

โ€œNo way. If I admitted it I think Mom would throw me out for desecrating Daniel Stone.โ€

โ€œPfft. Thatโ€™s only twenty percent of the reason. The other eighty is youโ€™re too attached.โ€

โ€œMaybe… I sort of am.โ€

โ€œAre you going to confess?โ€

I sat up and looked at Lily. โ€œDaniel gives me this vibe… like heโ€™s smiling at you but feels far away at the same time. I canโ€™t explain it.โ€

โ€œCold?โ€ she suggested.

โ€œA little.โ€

โ€œDonโ€™t fall too deep.โ€

She patted my head.

โ€œOkay.โ€

In the second semester of tenth grade I accidentally learned Danielโ€™s birthday.

Right. I, foolishly romantic, decided to give him a birthday gift.

I thought about it for ages, observed him, and couldnโ€™t tell what he liked. He seemed to like everything and nothing all at once.

So I decided asking him directly would be the most reliable plan.

โ€œMr. Stone.โ€

โ€œYes, what is it?โ€

โ€œDo you have anything you like?โ€

He looked a little surprised and pushed his glasses up. โ€œWhy are you asking this all of a sudden?โ€

โ€œJust… just suddenly, yes.โ€

I stammered and wanted to punch myself for being so awkward.

He looked out the window and was quiet for a moment. I thought my question was too abrupt and was about to drop it when he said, โ€œFireflies.โ€

โ€œHuh?โ€

โ€œI like fireflies.โ€

He smiled faintly, and I saw a trace of nostalgia in his eyes.

Perfect!

Except… easy to say, hard to do.

Iโ€™d lived in Hillside for so long and had never seen a single firefly.

What to do? Then a classmate told me heโ€™d seen them behind the school hill.

I was grateful beyond words.

It wasnโ€™t muchโ€”just a small slope, ten minutes to the top. Lily and I kept watch for three days. On the fourth day we finally saw them.

The day after that was Danielโ€™s birthday. The next day he was coming to tutor me, and my silly brain finally remembered the plan.

โ€œMr. Stone, are you free tomorrow night?โ€

โ€œYes? Why?โ€

He answered quickly.

โ€œI want to take you somewhere.โ€

โ€œAll right.โ€

He paused, then nodded.

It struck me as oddโ€”wouldnโ€™t someone usually have company on their birthday? Maybe his parents werenโ€™t in Hillside.

That night I caught a bad cold. I stared at the rain and wanted to curse the world.

โ€œWe still going?โ€ Daniel asked quietly.

โ€œYes.โ€

I packed up and told my mom. Worried, she held Danielโ€™s hand and fussed over me for a while.

Daniel and I shared an umbrella and left for the hill behind the school. He didnโ€™t ask me where we were going the whole way.

Luckily by the time we reached the back hill, the rain had almost stopped.

But the fireflies were nowhere to be seen.

โ€œMr. Stone, can you wait with me a little longer?โ€

I sniffled.

โ€œSure.โ€

After a while, my head started to get foggy from the coldโ€”I felt sleepy.

I was worrying about how to apologize to Mr. Stone when a single firefly drifted slowly past my face.

Instantly I perked up.

โ€œMr. Stone!
Mr. Stone!
A fireflyโ€”achoo.โ€

I pointed excitedly at that lone light.

โ€œI see it.โ€

He smiled and looked at me, then stepped beside me to watch the firefly.

I looked too. One light became two, then more, like stars in the night.

I turned toward him. He watched the lights with a look of nostalgia and fondness, a little smile at the corner of his mouth. He was so gentleโ€”I felt, for the first time, really close to him.

My heart fluttered.

On the way back, high on the beauty Iโ€™d seen, I slipped and took a hard fall.

I skinned my knee and started bleeding. Ridiculousโ€”one look at a pretty thing and I cause myself all this trouble.

Seeing me limp and thinking I might hurt myself again, Mr. Stone picked me up and carried me on his back.

Suddenly it felt worth it.

Damn this infuriating beauty.

I lay on his back and smelled a faint scent of herbal medicineโ€”comforting. Sleep washed over me.

โ€œHappy birthday, Mr. Stone.โ€

I said it, then surrendered to sleep.

I remember he might have answered me. Or maybe he didnโ€™t.

(15) Near the end of the second month of the fall semester of senior year.

Mr. Stone tutored me and gave me a notebook filled with detailed notes.

โ€œMay, keep it up.โ€

โ€œOkay.โ€

I hugged that notebook like it was treasure.

When he saw me out, he suddenly reached up and patted my head.

I froze, then bubbled over with happiness.

He opened the door, turned, and said gently, โ€œMay, goodbye.โ€

โ€œGoodbye, Mr. Stone.โ€

Watching him walk away, I had a bad feeling I couldnโ€™t name.

I pushed the unease down and told myself Iโ€™d see him next week.

But I never saw him again.

(16) I stopped staring at Evan Carter.

Maybe because Iโ€™d been playing simp to him for so long.

When I went to the cafeteria people asked why I wasnโ€™t trailing Evan anymore.

Usually I ignored them. Lily, tired of listening, would snap, โ€œMind your own business.โ€

Some laughed and said Iโ€™d go right back to simping in a few days.

A week passed, then two weeks, then a month.

People shifted from laughing to actually wondering what Evan had done.

Zoe would discreetly ask me if I wanted to join Evanโ€™s friend group when they hung out.

Iโ€™d smile and shake my head.

When I was simping for Evan, if I didnโ€™t go look for him, I barely saw him anywhere except the playground.

But when I stopped, suddenly he was everywhere.

Heโ€™d be with different girls. Sometimes our eyes would meet; Iโ€™d nod with a smile, and heโ€™d turn his head away.

I stopped greeting him. I ignored him.

And then, instead of me seeking him out, he started seeking me.

(17) Lily and I went downstairs and found Evan by the dorm lawn.

He was squatting at the edge of the grass, expressionless, the scar on his brow making him look fierce.

I assumed he was waiting for some girl and we walked past.

Then he said, โ€œMayโ€ฆโ€

โ€œDid you call me?โ€

I looked at Lily in confusion. She nodded, so I turned to him.

โ€œWhatโ€™s up?โ€

โ€œYouโ€ฆโ€

He hesitated, then, โ€œNever mind.โ€

โ€œOh.โ€

We left.

The next dayโ€”

When Lily and I headed to the cafeteria, he was there again.

โ€œMayโ€ฆโ€

He said softly.

โ€œDo you need something?โ€

I asked, puzzled.

โ€œNothingโ€ฆโ€

Third day, fourth day, fifth dayโ€ฆ I started to get a little afraid. Every time I passed Evan, heโ€™d call me in a slightly dark tone with a hoarse voice.

When I asked if something was wrong, he always said nothing.

โ€œWhy didnโ€™t I know he wasโ€ฆsick like this?โ€ I asked Lily in the dorm.

Lilyโ€™s eyes were complicated. โ€œNow you know, right?โ€

โ€œI thought you were joking when you called him weird before.โ€

โ€œTurns out I wasnโ€™t.โ€

โ€œHmm.โ€

I nodded.

(18) I stayed in the dorm for a few days, Lily brought me meals the whole time.

That wasnโ€™t a real solution.

Lily said she hadnโ€™t seen Evan for two days, so I decided to go downstairs with her.

Right outside the doorโ€”Evan was there again.

Honestly, I was startled.

I took a deep breath and walked up to him. โ€œEvan, are you really okay?โ€

โ€œIโ€™m fine.โ€

He stood up, glanced at me, and said, โ€œI just have a question.โ€

โ€œAsk.โ€

I thought, Why didnโ€™t you say that sooner?

โ€œIโ€ฆโ€

He hesitated. โ€œDoes my scar make me ugly?โ€

โ€œNo.โ€

I answered honestly.

โ€œThen, then whyโ€ฆโ€

He scratched his head. โ€œWhy did you stop chasing me?โ€

Now I was the one flustered. It took me a while to find my voice. โ€œHuh?โ€

โ€œI asked why you stopped chasing me.โ€

He sounded a little angry but repeated it.

โ€œYouโ€”you said you didnโ€™t like me.โ€

โ€œI do not like you, butโ€”butโ€”soโ€”โ€

He stammered then flared up in embarrassment, โ€œForget it!โ€

I stood there completely baffled.

(19) I had a bad feeling.

That week I ran into Evan in the cafeteria for the sixth time.

He insisted a girl heโ€™d planned to meet didnโ€™t like to eat and shoved a bottle of milk into my hand, ignoring me, then turned and left.

I looked at Lily. She looked exasperated.

A thought popped into my head.

โ€œLils, could heโ€ฆlike me?โ€

โ€œMaybeโ€ฆโ€

โ€œWhy?โ€

I racked my brain and came up empty.

โ€œMaybeโ€ฆheโ€™s just pathetic,โ€ Lily finally concluded.

(20) Evan somehow got word of my routine.

From then on, whenever I left the dorm, I could find him somewhere handing me thingsโ€”candies, cookies, drinks.

I told him I didnโ€™t need them, but he didnโ€™t stop.

I couldnโ€™t bring myself to throw them awayโ€”maybe because Evanโ€™s features reminded me a little of Mr. Stone.

I took the treats back and shared them with my roommates.

A semester passed like that.

Evan and I were still campus fixtures at Waverly Universityโ€”just in different roles.

When I asked Lily for advice again, she sighed. โ€œMouse, if nothing else works, why donโ€™t you try dating Evan?โ€

(21) In the spring semester of our junior year, the neighboring university celebrated its centennial with lots of events and opened its gates.

Lily and I decided to go check it out.

Inside there were booths everywhere.

They even shoved flyers with QR codes into our hands.

We exchanged a helpless smile.

There was a homemade haunted house that actually was pretty creepy.

After being scared, Lily and I wandered with bottled water. The deeper into the campus we went, the quieter it got.

Different school, same school vibesโ€”still feels novel.

I fiddled with a toy in my hand when Lily suddenly stopped.

She stared ahead, surprised.

Curious, I followed her gaze.

A magnolia tree spread its branches, white blooms swaying in the breeze, sweet scent in the air. Under the tree stood a man.

Black hair, a straight nose, thin-frame glasses. He looked up at the flowers.

He must have noticed our looks, because he turned toward us with mild surprise.

I knew the face and my eyes filled. It took me a long moment before I could choke out the word.

โ€œMr. Stoneโ€ฆโ€

(22)

Iโ€™d imagined meeting Mr. Stone in a hundred ways.

Maybe alone, maybe with a girlfriend, maybe with his child. Iโ€™d rehearsed looking composed, acting like a delighted old friend: โ€œLong time no see, Mr. Stone. How have you been?โ€

Iโ€™d planned out a thousand reactions, but when it actually happened, all the rehearsed dignity fell apart.

None of the poised smiles mattered.

He walked toward me and stopped about a meter away, using that familiar gentle voice to call, โ€œMay.โ€

I brought my hand up to my mouth. Iโ€™d meant to smile, but tears welled instead.

My first thought: my outfit sucks today.

He wore a white shirt and blue pantsโ€”exactly as I remembered. He stood so near I could reach out and touch him.

He smiled quietly, as if nothing had ever happened.

(23) โ€œMouse.
Mouse!โ€

Lily shook my shoulder hard and I snapped back. Iโ€™d been mindlessly patting cushion foundation on my face; now I looked a mess.

I set the cushion down and met Lilyโ€™s eyes. She took two tissues from the box and handed them to me.

My face was streaked with tears. I mopped at it clumsily.

The dorm was empty; the room was silent except for my sniffing.

I stopped crying. Lily gently wrapped an arm around me and patted my back. โ€œGo take off your makeup and get in bed.โ€

โ€œOkay.โ€

I nodded, went to remove my makeup, then lay on my bed staring at the ceiling until sleep came.

Premium chapters locked

Unlock the rest of the story

200 Book Coins

The next scene of The Moment I Stopped Loving Him begins with: When I first saw Mr. Stone, my body acted faster than my brain. Before Iโ€™d decided what to do, I grabbed Lilyโ€™s hand and ran…. Continue with the remaining 637 story sections.

Get Book Coins to Unlock