A decade of secret longingโat this moment, I finally gave up.
1. Ethan got into a car accident. His right leg was fractured; heโd be bedridden for at least a month.
He couldnโt take care of himself and would need help.
After Mom nagged me again and again, I brought a pot of congee to the hospital.
Ethan really was wealthyโhe had a single room.
I couldnโt help but sigh.
He was reading. When he heard me, he looked up and met my eyes.
Not long ago Iโd sworn I wouldnโt bother him anymore; yet here I was, showing up at his door barely two days later. I stood awkwardly in the doorway.
Iโd said the same things so many times over the years that Ethan had become immune to my โresolves.โ His attitude had shifted from annoyed coldness to complete indifference. That day, after I spoke, I even caught a flash of mocking disdain in his eyes.
Actually, โso many timesโ was an exaggerationโreally, only three times.
Every failed attempt to walk away only convinced him that I couldnโt live without him.
He didnโt know that every time I tried, I was sincerely crushed. My disappointment and hurt were real. My desire to give up was real.
This time it felt different. I think I wasnโt as in love anymore.
I hadnโt wanted to come.
But my mom said, โYouโre free during the day. You can help look after Little Ethan. Youโve been neighbors for yearsโheโs like your brother. The kids should watch out for each other.โ Before I could refuse, Ethanโs mom called and, sounding grateful, asked if I could look after her son.
I said, โBut Ethan has a girlfriend.โ โA girlfriend? Ethan has a girlfriend?โ Her voice was shocked.
Minutes later Mom called again. โYour aunt checkedโEthan said he doesnโt have a girlfriend. You must be mistaken.โ โฆHeโs just not ready to tell you.
I poured the seafood congee from the thermos; the room filled with a savory aroma.
I handed him a bowl. He glanced at me and took it without comment.
After one spoonful he frowned. โDid you buy this?โ I nodded and sat down. โI was in a rushโdidnโt have time to cook.โ Ethan pursed his lips.
โJust eat some for now. Iโll make you a proper meal next time.โ Ethan didnโt like restaurant foodโhe thought it was unclean, and he disliked heavy seasonings.
Seafood congee took effort: four or five ingredients, deveining shrimp, all that. If it were the old days, I mightโve started cooking an hour or two early to have it ready.
Soon, Chloe Park arrived.
The heat had rouged her cheeks; she came in breathless, smiling, โEthan, I brought you congeeโI made it myself.โ I noticed she wore a tight denim skirt.
What made me care so much was the first time Iโd seen them: Ethan had smiled at her, appreciating, โYou look good in skirts.โ Contrast that with the many times Iโd worn a skirt and other guys stared at my legs while Ethan scrunched his brow and asked, โWhy would you wear something like that?โ Because of that comment Iโd hardly worn skirts since.
I racked my brain wondering what kind of girl got that approving โyou look goodโ from Ethan.
Conclusion: Chloe was thin, with a great waist-to-hip ratio and long straight dark hair. Any skirt on her would read as graceful.
So I dieted hardโskin sallow from hunger, listlessโuntil I dropped under 95 pounds.
Maya scolded me in despair: โYouโre paler, slimmer waist, perkier chest, a beautiful swan neckโno matter what, if a man doesnโt like you, he just doesnโt. Why canโt you see that?โ
โI know,โ I told her, โbut I canโt help it.โ
The skirt Chloe wore now looked a lot like the one Ethan had criticized me for: short, clinging to the hip line.
When I noticed Chloeโs outfit, Ethanโs expression didnโt change at all.
So it wasnโt the skirt. It was the person.
โThanks, but I already ate.โ Ethan put his bowl down.
โOh.โ Chloe looked a little disappointed.
I took the thermos. โNo worriesโput it in the fridge and heat it up at night.โ That way I wouldnโt need to cook.
I opened the lid and breathed in, secretly pleased.
Ethan glanced at me.
They chatted while I sat with my head down on my phone.
Ethan was clearly more attentive to Chloeโhe even handed her a blanket to cover her legs.
I rested my head on the table and, without realizing it, fell asleep.
2. I always knew Ethan didnโt like me.
Weโd known each other too long. My short buzz-cut and dirty tank-top, running around sun-darkened as a kidโthose images stuck in his mind.
Even through middle school when I was a tomboy, to him I was that skinny neighborhood kid; my gender barely registered.
Even after I grew my hair out in high school and got compliments on my figure, his impression never changed.
The latest blow came when I overheard him joking to Chloe about me: offhand, โYaoโpeople know not to go for whatโs nearby.โ Even so, Iโd still stand at his door with a bowl of breakfast, try to compose myself, and pretend everything was normal.
I was afraid that if I called him out, our last fragile ties would snap.
Pathetic. I even found myself laughing at how low Iโd stooped.
A few days earlier, I bumped into Chloe wrapped in only a towel in Ethanโs room.
She had just come out of the bathroom, hair still dripping, shoulders bare and smooth. Without makeup she looked even more innocent.
We stared at each other; she was shocked, squeaked briefly, and hid behind Ethan.
The master bedroom door was open; inside the light was dim and intimate.
I smelled a faint metallic tang in the air.
Ethan, oh Ethanโmy crush for ten yearsโwas in bed with another girl today.
Although she seemed flustered, we both knew who was worse off. It was me.
I kept my composure and handed over my phone. โAunt May couldnโt reach you and got worriedโshe called me.โ Ethan glanced at me, expression flat, took the phone and walked away. โHey, Mom. Iโm here.โ He didnโt care about what I thought.
I lowered my eyes so I wouldnโt have to meet Chloeโs gaze.
This girl had been coming to Ethanโs house every morning for a whole month and would only leave around six or seven each evening. Sometimes sheโd run into me and still smile hello.
Before, he never let girls come and go from his houseโexcept me. Now even that exception was gone.
Jealousy nagged me. Her smile seemed threaded with irony and showiness.
Shouldnโt I be relieved that she hadnโt stayed the night? I convinced myself of thatโuntil I got slapped in the face.
After Mom finished talking on the phone, Ethan handed it back and explained, โI didnโt notice my phone turned off.โ โOkay.โ I kept my face neutral. โIโll go.โ
Ethan stared at me a long moment, his expression unreadable. โFine.โ I turned, but Chloe called after me.
A little embarrassed, she said, โI drank too much last nightโmy clothes smell. Can I borrow something of yours?โ She tilted her mouth into a smile. โI think our sizes are similar.โ I paused then turned back with a small smile. โSure.โ Later I sat in the dim room for a long time. I donโt want to remember how that night went; when youโre truly helpless, you rarely cry much.
I knew what a woman showering at a single manโs place implied. I didnโt want to imagine what had happened between them or how, but those images invaded my head anyway. By the time I realized, my own nails had dug into my palm until it was purple.
Staring at the ringed nail marks, I felt unbearably sad.
After that I decided to let go. I even planned to leave the city.
Then, a couple days later, Ethan had the accident.
When he woke, it was already night. I rubbed my sore arm and asked, groggy, โWhereโs Chloe?โ Ethan, terse, โShe left.โ
I wondered if theyโd fought. He closed his laptop, rubbed his forehead. โBring me the chamber pot under the bed.โ I blinked. โOhโฆokay.โ He lifted the covers and I saw the blue-and-white striped hospital pajamas.
I couldnโt look. โDo you want me to look away?โ He half-smiled.
โSuit yourself.โ
3. I was staying overnight to keep watch, so I kept glancing toward Ethan to see if he was planning to sleep.
Around eleven he finally shut his computer. โBring a hot towel. I want to wipe up.โ โWipe up?โ Well, he hadnโt showered since the crashโa good three days.
I brought the towel. Ethan was unbuttoning his shirt.
As he pulled it off, his chest and abs appearedโlean but not scrawny, muscles smooth and defined.
If it had been before, my face would have flushed and Iโd be too embarrassed to look.
Who among us isnโt a little bit lecherous with the one we like?
He took the towel and wiped his neck and arms.
His chest rose and fell with each breath.
I found myself distracted.
After a while he handed the towel to me. โGo wash it.โ โOkay.โ I went like a dutiful little wife.
I rinsed the towel, but he didnโt take it back. โYour back.โ I understood and carefully wiped his back.
His skin under my hands was smooth and resilientโdifferent from a womanโs softer skin.
Ethan didnโt speak until I reached his waist, when he suddenly pressed my hand down.
โDone?โ I asked.
He glanced at me without showing much.
โDo I need to wipe belowโtoo?โ
I froze after asking.
Ethan stiffened too, lowering his eyes with a complex look.
Oh no.
I regretted it. How could I have flirted with a man who might have a girlfriend? He would surely misunderstand.
โMaybe we should get a nurse?โ I suggested after finishing, trying to be earnest.
Ethan frowned. โDo you think Iโm a nuisance?โ โOr next time wait until Chloeโs here?โ I said. โAfter all, sheโs your girlfriend.โ Ethan replied, โSheโs not my girlfriend.โ Theyโd slept together and she wasnโt his girlfriend?
Ethan, when did you get so awful?
4.
I told Maya about the night I accidentally walked in on Chloe showering at Ethanโs house.
She ground her teeth. โAt this point youโre not still head-over-heels for him, are you?โ I rubbed my face. โI was over it. I was actually planning to leave and go back to Riverside.
But didnโt Ethan get into a car accident?
My mom asked me to stay and take care of him for a while.โ
โWait, I think my brother works in Arbor City. Let me ask.โ Maya said magnanimously. โIโll introduce him to you! Heโs really handsome.โ โWhen did you get a brother?โ โCousinโolder cousin. Iโll have him add you on WeChat.โ A few minutes later, someone named JL sent a friend request.
We added him and didnโt say anything.
He probably wasnโt interested in me, just didnโt want to be rude.
I didnโt care much and forgot about it.
It took about a weekโafter X-rays confirmed his fracture hadnโt shiftedโbefore Ethan could be discharged.
During that time, Chloe came to visit him every day.
She brought fruit, mealsโsaved me a lot of trouble.
Ethan was polite to her. In fact he was polite to everyone, except with me he never put on a pretense.
Chloe asked me, concerned, if I needed to go home and rest, that she could stay and watch over him.
โReally?โ I hadnโt been sleeping well in the hospitalโEthan sometimes had to get up at night, sometimes needed water. I woke at least twice every night.
She smiled sweetly. โOf course.โ From the bed Ethan glanced over at us, his look heavy.
I picked up my bag. โIโll come back tonight.โ As I left, I saw Ethan press his lips togetherโhis sign he was mad.
In freshman year heโd had a bad fluโhigh fever that wouldnโt breakโand refused to go to the hospital. I couldnโt carry him, so I stayed up all night in our rented room, doing everything I could to cool him down, my eyes burning from lack of sleep.
Two students alone in a new town, with nowhere to turn. That night I felt helpless.
Luckily the fever broke the next day and he came to, opening his eyes and looking at me without a word.
I had held in my tears all night and finally let them fall. I stammered, asking if he was hungry, what he wanted to eat.
It was flu season. Ethan asked if I wasnโt afraid of getting sick.
I, being hopelessly romantic, said, โIโd rather it be me who gets sick.โ Ethan was silent.
If it had been back then, I wouldnโt have trusted Ethanโfresh from an accidentโto another woman.
โฆ โCareful.โ Lost in the memory, I almost walked into someone in the hospital corridor. A manโs index finger tapped my forehead, stopping me before I bumped into him. His tone held no blame.
I looked up, a little stunned. It was a very young doctor, tallโat least a head taller than meโin a white coat, with especially sharp brows and a sculpted nose.
He smiled at me, glanced at the room behind me, then walked past.
A thought crossed my mind.
So other guys can be that handsome too.
5.
That night, on the bus to the hospital, Maya texted me: Her โbrotherโ had stopped by to see me, thought I was cute.
Me: ???
When?
Maya: Heโll tell you himself. He said I couldnโt say.
So I went into Ethanโs room full of questions.
A man sat on the edge of the bed, a bandage across his forehead. He beamed when he saw me. โClaireโs here.โ Ethan said. โThis is Chloeโs brother, Lucas.โ โHaha, you might not know me yet, but Iโve known about you for a while.โ Lucas stood and greeted me.
The Night I Found Him With Her
Ethan expressionless: โHe was the driver that night.โ โHey, I didnโt mean it. I got hurt tooโhurt my face,โ Lucas thumped Ethanโs plastered leg and then looked at me nervously. โClaire, please donโt blame me.โ โOkay, you can leave now.โ โYou wonโt tell me and Iโll really go.โ Lucas mumbled as he left.
I took out the clean clothes Iโd picked up at Ethanโs place. โSo what happened that night? How did the accident happen?โ He didnโt answer.
Ethanโs fastidiousโtwo days without washing his hair is his limit. I filled a basin and dry-washed his hair, rubbing his scalp through the suds. Ethan closed his eyes; even in repose his features were hauntingly handsome.
The air filled with a small, tender warmth. Only in moments like this did I allow myself to believe maybe he felt something for me too.
That feeling was stitched with habit and trustโbut not the love I wanted.
As I blow-dried his hair I couldnโt help running my fingers through it. His hair was glossy black, silkyโsomething even I envied.
Ethan took my wrist and curled my right hand into his palm.
I look small-boned and lean, but I actually hold a lot of hidden softness. Maya always hugged me, saying I was squishy and warm and easy to hold.
Maybe because of that, Ethan liked to pinch my palmโcasually gripping my hand, rubbing and fiddling. My palm is sensitive; his touch always made my ears heat and my temperature climb. It pulled my thoughts away.
I didnโt know if he noticed. I used to love him and suffered for it; I always put up with it and sometimes felt a little sweetness too.
This time I pulled my hand back.
Ethanโs palm was empty. He looked up at me; his gaze dimmed.
See? Not loving him anymore wasnโt that hard.
โฆ The next morning, the chief physician came round with a few doctors and I saw that handsome doctor again.
He stood behind the chief and gave me a small smile.
After the routine checkup the chief nodded, said the recovery was good and gave some instructions before they left.
That doctor hung back, glanced at Ethanโs chart. โDischarge the day after tomorrow?โ I answered โMm.โ
โSo soon?โ He said something I didnโt catch.
His eyes swept across my face and he smiled. โHi, Claire, Iโm Dr. Ryan Wells.โ And he left.
Suddenly it clicked.
Ryan? JL?
Ethan asked, โWho is he?โ I blankly said, โI think heโs the one Maya introduced me to.โ
6.
On the day Ethan was discharged, Chloe came again.
I hustled through the paperwork while she whispered to Ethan, sitting very close with her hand on his arm.
I sighed.
This is the tragedy of the simp.
They were romantically involved, and I was trying to figure out how to get reimbursed for medical bills.
In a panic I lost Ethanโs insurance card and nearly had a meltdown. Luckily I ran into Dr. Ryan; he helped me look all over and we found the card at the front deskโone of the nurses had picked it up. Seeing me scattered, he personally walked me to the discharge window to settle the bill.
He looked at my many bags and asked if I wanted help.
I felt awkward. โWonโt it take up your timeโฆ?โ He smiled, and his voice was pleasant. โIf itโs you, it wonโt.โ Even his teasing was adorable.
Dr. Ryan carried my luggage down to the hospital garage and helped Ethanโstiff and awkwardโinto the car. When that was done he glanced at the other two and then back at me. โIโll be going. If anything comes up during recovery contact me. If you have any questions, reach out.โ I nodded, full of gratitude. โThank you, Dr. Wells.โ He smiled and waved.
Ethan never spoke the whole time.
Chloe, all bright-eyed, asked me in the car, โBoyfriend?โ I opened the car door and hesitated. โNot really.โ
Ethan has been my neighborโfor years as kids, and now again.
To stay close to him right after graduation I scrimped and lived in a tiny place twenty miles from my office, devoting half my salary to rent and always budgeting for tomorrowโs meals.
Only when my freelance writing paid better did things ease.
It made caring for him convenient now.
Ethan was unusually quiet today. Even Chloeโs chatter on the drive didnโt interest him much. I was used to his coldness and didnโt read into it.
His orthopedic injury wasnโt severe; he could wash himself but was supposed to minimize movement.
My mom FaceTimed and told me to watch him so he didnโt fall alone.
I moved my laptop to his apartmentโmy content output slipped while I was taking care of him and I got slammed by readers for missing updates.
What could I say? I was taking care of my crush.
He already had someone, even if he didnโt want to call her his girlfriend.
The readers probably thought I was the other woman.
Dr. Ryan used patient check-ins as a reason to chat, and I used follow-up questions as an excuse to banter. We both knew it.
After a while I wanted to go see him for an examโbut he wasnโt a gynecologist, so Iโd actually have to hurt myself to find a reason to see him.
Interestingly, since his concussion cleared, Lucas came by often with his fashion sketches and finished pieces to discuss with Ethan.
They wanted to start an online shop focused on original designs and turned Ethanโs place into their studio. Chloe modeled for them.
โThereโs already a ready-made model here. My sisterโs look is too one-note for some of these pieces.โ Lucas stroked his chin and appraised me.
Ethan closed his eyes and didnโt look my way. โSheโs not right,โ he said. Lucas shrugged helplessly.
I smiled faintly, said nothing.
I no longer crumbled at every offhand critique from him.
That night I sat on the balcony, talking to my mom on video. Halfway through she brought Ethan up with a gentle tone. โYou canโt force love. If it was meant to be, it wouldโve happened by nowโฆโ I said, โMom, I think I donโt like him that much anymore.โ She paused.
It was the first time I said it so calmly. Back when I was most upset I would have cried and shouted, Ethan, you think Iโll die if Iโm not with you? Donโt worry, I wonโt cling to you anymore.
Iโd never once said, I donโt like him.
Mom nodded and said nothing.
When I ended the call and turned around, Ethan stood behind me, expressionless, watching.
7.
Two weeks later, Dr. Ryan finally asked me out.
For our date I wore a dress I thought was really pretty.
Seeing Dr. Ryan outside the hospital felt strange at first.
He took off his white coat and wore a more casual shirtโnarrow waist, long legs, clean-cut. He gave off the air of a talented young man. I had no idea Maya had such a handsome older cousin.
He studied me for a moment. "That's not your usual style."
I got nervous. "I hardly ever wear dresses."
"Hmm. Looking this good means you should wear them less often," he said.
I blinked and looked up at him.
He smiled, his eyes gentle.
Suddenly I relaxed.
The rest of the day I finally understood what it's like for a girl to be doted on by a boyfriend.
Dr. Ryan seemed especially patient with girls. At lunch it was sweltering, and I casually said I wanted a peach Frappuccino. He told me to wait at the table and went to stand in line at Starbucks for over ten minutes.
When I bragged to Maya about him on WeChat, she was incredulous. Every time she wanted bubble tea or dessert, Dr. Ryan would warn her about the sugar and how it could mess up her skinโhe'd never gone out of his way to buy anything for her.
"He hasn't even bought me a lollipop my whole life," Maya complained. "Hey, ask him what he'd do if you broke out after drinking that milk tea."
When Dr. Ryan came back, I relayed her question word for word.
He handed me the Frappuccino and sat across from me without a fuss. "You have neutral skin. You're not prone to acne. And even if you do get some, I know a bit about dermatology."
I praised him sincerely. "You're amazing."
He curved his lips in a small smile.
When he smiled, he looked like sunshineโclean, refreshing.
Most important, his eyes were on me.
Not like Ethan, who was always cold. With Ethan I had to tiptoe, anticipate his likes and mood swings, keep my heart dangling in the air, rising and falling with him.
Sometimes when we talked I'd apologize for wasting his time. "Doctors must be very busy."
"They are," he said, "which is why I wanted to talk to you." It had been four or five days since our last date.
I was just thinking about him when his message came through: Want to go see a movie tonight?
So this is what mutual attraction feels like. It wasn't all sour compromise and insecurity. While I was timid and afraid to make a move, he was trying to get closer, too.
The movie ended late and Dr. Ryan drove me home.
The car stopped outside my complex. When I got out, he naturally took my hand and it made my small heart leap.
I even surprised myself.
"Which building do you live in?" he asked.
"Building 27," I said. "It's only a minute or two walk."
He nodded. "I'll walk you to the lobby." I checked the timeโafter eleven-thirty. Ethan should've been asleep.
He'd just had his cast removed two days ago and could move around more. He didn't need me watching over him every moment anymore.
So I asked him to take a little detour around the complex so we could have a few more minutes together. I don't know if he noticed my nervesโI certainly felt guilty.
Fate did what it was going to do. Five minutes later we stopped steady in front of my building's entrance.
"Good night," I said reluctantly.
"Yaoโ" He called my name, then closed the distance, placed his hand at my waist, and kissed me.
When he let go I gasped, almost collapsing against him; I only stayed upright because his arm supported me.
His voice was low and slightly hoarse. "Claire, you're too sensitive." I was mortified; my whole face felt like it was burning.
At the same time, a thrilling numbness kept starting at my tailbone and traveling up.
I was a little pervert and yet I'd never had a boyfriend.
Dr. Ryan whispered near my ear, "If you act like that, I'll want to kiss you again."
I buried my face against his shoulder and pretended not to understand.
Then a familiar male voice came from behind us: "Claire." My heart dropped. I slowly turnedโit was Ethan.
Why was he still outside so late?
Half his face vanished into the darkness; I couldn't read his expression.
I felt awkward, but I didn't let go of Dr. Ryan's hand. I held his gaze for a beat, then said softly, "Be careful on your way." He nodded, glanced at Ethan, and slipped past him to leave.
I said nothing and swiped my card to open the building door, then went inside.
Ethan followed and got into the elevator with me.
Being caught in the middle of your first kiss would make me embarrassed by a strangerโlet alone Ethan, who'd grown up with me. I didn't know how to face him.
"To kiss someone you've only met a few times." As we stepped out of the elevator, Ethan's voice was cool and cutting. "Claire, when did you get so casual?"
Casual?
Who did he think he was to say that?
A rush of anger filled my chest.
"Ethan, I'm an adult." I turned to him and tried to keep my tone calm. "Dating is normal. And we justโkissed once."
"So a few days of knowing someone is enough to kiss them? What's nextโsleeping with them?" he snapped.
"And so what if I did?" I answered hotly. "Maybe to you I don't count as a woman, but to him I do!" With a thud Ethan punched the wall behind me.
I'd never seen him so angry.
The eyes that were usually indifferent were bloodshot now. He glared at me, his thin lips going white.
Ethanโwhat are you even mad about?
9.
The next two days, Ethan shut himself away.
He even turned his cousin Lucas away at the door.
Ethan's mother came by to ask about him. I gave her Chloe Park's number and told her it was her son's girlfriend.
Half an hour later there was a knock. I opened the door to see Ethan dark-faced, holding up his phone and accusing me, "Why did you give my mom Chloe's number?"
I replied calmly, "I just told her to contact the right person." Ethan's Adam's apple bobbed.
…After that night, Dr. Ryan asked if Ethan had done anything to me after he left.
I said, "He wouldn't do anything. He's just worriedโafter all, we grew up together. I'm sort of like a half-sister." Dr. Ryan asked, "Do you really believe he only sees you as a sister?" I fell silent.
But if he didn'tโwhat did all those years of mine mean?
"You're living so close to him. I'm not comfortable with that," Dr. Ryan said plainly. "The apartment next to mine is owned by a friend and it's been vacant. I'm looking for renters. The rent would be much cheaper than what you're paying now. Do you want to consider it?"
A year ago another girl had liked Ethan. When she found out where he lived she tried everything to steal the apartment across from me. The lease hadn't been signed yet; for Ethan I had gritted my teeth and agreed to pay twenty percent more.
That girl kept hounding me afterwardโharassing me, mocking that Ethan would never like me and telling me not to hog what I didn't deserve.
I thought for a moment, then texted: Do you still want the place?
She was surprised. Are you serious? You said you'd never leave that apartment.
No wonder she was stunned. Back then I was so broke I couldn't even afford new underwear. I hadn't thought about moving somewhere cheaper.
I typed on my computer and sent a voice message, "Yes. The place is tiny and expensive. I want a change." She hesitated forever before saying okay. "Don't regret it," she warned.
"But I need to tell you somethingโEthan already has a girlfriend. If you're moving in because of him, it might not matter."
"Who says I'm moving in alone?" she laughed. "I also know the girl you mentioned." I froze, then realized what she meant.
Was Chloe planning to move in?
The next day Ethan knocked on my door again.
Lately he'd been coming over more in two days than he used to in a month.
When I opened the door his expression was tight and dark, like he wanted to say something. He stopped when he saw the packed boxes in my room. "You're moving?"
I said, "Mm."
He hadn't spoken for a long time. I turned to keep packing, but his hand grabbed mine.
"Who are you moving in with?" His voice was low. "Dr. Ryan?"
I took a breath. "That's none of your business." Ethan nearly crushed my wrist; his tone was frighteningly cold. "Claire, do you know what it means to live with a man?"
I winced from the pain. "I'm twenty-four. I can take care of myself."
He stepped forward. "So you two are that far along?" I pursed my lips and said nothing.
"What do you even like about him?" Ethan sounded angrier than before. He closed in on me, his words sharp and almost mocking. "Just because he touches you?"
I backed up a few steps, my face hot with shame.
My mind flashed back to sophomore year. I had nursed a bitter secret crush and couldn't decide whether to confess. I finally mustered courage only to see Ethanโunconcerned and unbotheredโunder the plane trees outside school, kissing another girl.
My world had shattered. His hand rested on that girl's shoulder; he had his eyes closed, relaxed and gentle.
I tasted jealousy for the first time and felt ashamed.
He might not have loved that girl deeply; maybe it was teenage curiosity. But that scene made me realize he'd never look at me that way.
In his eyes I wasn't even a woman.
So why was he angry when another man kissed me?
I looked up at him. "Yes, I like him. I'm willing to kiss him." It was a sticky summer; I wore an oversized T-shirt and gray shorts. The hem of the shirt barely covered my shorts.
Ethan's fingers dug into my shoulders. His hand slid down my back under my shirt and sent a thrill through me.
I'm extremely sensitiveโsomeone just squeezing my palm can make me blush. My breath stopped entirely.
His hand found the clasp of my bra; he stared into my eyes. "Claire, is this what you want?"
I couldn't believe it. I pushed him away. "Ethan, are you crazy?"
He watched me in silence, his gaze slowly dimming.
…I had most of my stuff packed. On moving day, Dr. Ryan came to help.
When he picked up a photo from my high school years to study, I quickly hid it.
โYou showed me your middle school photos, Maya did,โ he said with a crooked smile. โShort hair looked sharp on you.โ
โNonsense. If Iโd looked like that, would you still like me?โ I teased.
He thought for a beat. โAs long as you donโt change genders, Iโm good.โ
โโฆโ The movers were finishing up, hauling the last boxes out. I stood in the middle of the empty apartment and took one last look around.
I came to Riverside because of Ethan, and now I was staying for Dr. Ryan.
As we were about to leave, Ethanโs door opened.
There were dark circles under his eyesโhe mustโve been up all nightโand he said my name slowly, โClaire.โ He didnโt seem to notice Dr. Ryan behind me. He reached out and took my wrist. โDonโt move. Please.โ
It was such a rare, vulnerable plea.
I couldnโt put my feelings into words.
11. Riding in Dr. Ryanโs car, he noticed I was quiet and didnโt press meโjust kind.
Ethanโs sudden change didnโt make me waver.
I just didnโt understand.
How could he be dating someone else and still expect me to be there like before?
What did I actually mean to him?
We moved into the apartment next to Dr. Ryanโs and spent half the day unpacking. By the time we finished, we collapsed onto the couch.
โHungry?โ I asked.
He hummed.
โLetโs order takeout?โ I was too tired to lift a finger.
He shot me a playful look, tugged me up off the couch, and took me inside to make a bowl of pasta.
โFrom now on, weโre neighbors,โ he said. โA lot easier to do stuff.โ
I pretended not to get it. โLike what?โ
Dr. Ryan smiled without answering.
My brain started filling with silly possibilities, so I forced myself to focus and eat.
A few days later, Maya called and asked if her cousin treated me wellโwhether he bullied me.
I told her no way; Dr. Ryan was a good man.
Maya huffed and told me about his past relationshipsโtwo girlfriends, both relationships ending within a year. Both complained that his mind was never really in it. He seemed easygoing but could be strangely distant.
Once, when he was caught cheating, heโd stayed calm. He didnโt seem to believe in love.
Maya said she only introduced him to me to distract me and help me move on from Ethan. She never imagined weโd actually get together.
How much of Dr. Ryanโs attention was genuine, and how much was him wanting a girlfriend or doing Maya a favor? I didnโt know. Frankly, I didnโt care.
I just wanted a normal relationship.
I funneled all the energy Iโd given Ethan into this oneโpaying attention to what Dr. Ryan liked, timing his walks home, cooking a spread of his favorite dishes.
He came home, saw the food, hesitated for a moment, then washed his hands and sat down quietly.
โYou donโt like it?โ I asked, puzzled. โIf somethingโs wrong, Iโll fix it next time.โ
He shook his head. โI havenโt had a meal this suited to my taste in a long time.โ He was gentle, considerate of my feelings.
But something still felt off.
After we started dating, Dr. Ryan gave me all his free time.
He watched movies with me, played games with me, dragged my usually sedentary self to the gym and acted as my unpaid personal trainer. I could feel him taking the relationship seriously.
And yet there always seemed to be a layer between us.
I couldnโt figure out why.
Then one day he came home at six in the morning, having been gone all night. Iโd been up late working on updates and, exhausted, I made him a hot bowl of dumplings.
โWhy didnโt you reply to my messages?โ I yawned. โWhy didnโt you come home last night?โ
He didnโt answer at first; he just looked at the dumplings.
I thought he didnโt want to talk and didnโt push. I pulled out a chair and sat down, heavy with sleep, trying to at least eat with him.
โAre you that nice to him too?โ Dr. Ryan asked quietly.
I froze.
โHe doesnโt answer your messages, doesnโt come home, and you donโt complainโstill worried he mightโve missed breakfast,โ he said. โJust thinking that someone else once got treated that way makes my chest feel tight.โ Heโd heard about me and Ethan from Maya a few times and had laughed. Who would be that foolish? He used to pity me. Now he soundedโฆjealous.
He met my eyes. โLast night we had an emergencyโthe patientโs five fingers were mangled by a machine. We did six hours of surgery, then had to talk to the family. Thatโs why I couldnโt reply.โ He was explaining.
I nodded, opened my mouth to say something, and closed it.
โMy patience seems to be shrinking,โ he said with a wry twist of his mouth. A touch of self-mockery. โI even find myself comparing. Can I beat Ethan in your heart?โ He paused. โBut I really like you.โ He tried to pick his words carefully. โSeeing you makes me happy. I wait for you to come home. I evenโฆthought about losing my pride and moving in with you.โ
The last sentence popped out and I immediately regretted it, jumping up from the chair.
Trying to prove my loyalty had accidentally revealed my shameless side.
โReally?โ He took my hand, smiling, refusing to let me hide. โYou want to move in with me?โ
โโฆDo we move in together?โ He wrapped his arm around my waist.
โYes.โ Sigh. Moving again.
โIโm such a hopeless fangirl. Boohoo. If we reach 11k likes Iโll let Dr. Ryan take the lead