Wrong Package, Right Crush

Wrong Package, Right Crush cover

Wrong Package, Right Crush

I grabbed the wrong packageโ€”and inside was a whole box of extra-large couple’s toys.

I almost handed it back then and there, until I saw who the delivery was for.

It was my long-time secret crush from campus, the underclassman I’d been quietly orbiting for years.

He told me he didn’t have a girlfriend. I believed him.

But then his roommate showed up and slung an arm over his shoulders, grinning, "Whoa, already arrived?"

I got a box of… well, you know.

To be exact, I grabbed the wrong package.

Normally, to avoid mix-ups Iโ€™d even picked a loud, unmistakable recipient nameโ€”โ€œSunny Delivery.โ€

Six hahs. Loud enough, right?

And yet, in the rush at noon today, I still picked the wrong box.

I opened it back in the dorm and discovered all the earrings and hair accessories Iโ€™d ordered had been replaced by a box full of T-shirts.

What theโ€”?

More than that, I wanted to know whose delivery name could make me misread it so badly.

I squinted at the label and nearly choked.

The recipient name on that box read: โ€œSunny, My Foot.โ€

Then I checked the phone numberโ€”both numbers looked similar to the campus card ones, and both ended in 03.

Ugh.

I was about to call the real owner when I noticed, on every single package, three words stamped loud and clear: โ€œPlus Size.โ€

I couldnโ€™t help but click my tongue. Dudeโ€™s well-developed, huh.

After teasing my roommates about it, I dialed the number on the slip.

The voice on the other end was a nice-sounding boyโ€”and, voice-wise, he even slightly resembled the underclassman Iโ€™d had a crush on for ages.

I explained Iโ€™d accidentally taken his package and asked when I could return it.

There was a few secondsโ€™ silence, then he asked in a low voice, โ€œYouโ€ฆhavenโ€™t opened it, right?โ€

I paused a beat and lied to avoid awkwardness. โ€œNo. I was about to open it and saw the name didnโ€™t match, so I called right away.โ€

He seemed to breathe easier. โ€œOkay, letโ€™s meet at the Campus Cafeteria entrance in ten minutes.โ€

He even added politely at the end, โ€œThanks for the trouble.โ€

I thought it would be just a simple package mix-up. I was wrong.

Ten minutes later I stood at the east entrance of the Campus Cafeteria, holding the box Iโ€™d re-taped, staring, stunned, at the boy in front of meโ€”the โ€œPlus Sizeโ€ guy.

The boy turned out to be my underclassman crush.

Of course.

His name was Ethan Carter, a year below me, a sophomore.

True to his name, he was clean and clear, like a young poplar treeโ€”slender and upright and absolutely beautiful.

He was the sort of genuinely good-looking guy youโ€™d call a total catch.

Iโ€™d run into him around campus many times, but he always felt like one of those people you admire from afarโ€”you could look, but not touch.

This was maybe the first time Iโ€™d been this close to him.

The package suddenly felt unexpectedly hot in my hands. I checked, โ€œIs this yours?โ€

He skimmed the slip and nodded, lips pressed lightly together. โ€œYesโ€ฆโ€

Ethan looked especially good todayโ€”in a white tee, like heโ€™d just had a haircut, short black hair brushing his forehead, clean-cut and handsome.

We were about two steps apart. A breeze hit and I could smell him.

A faint, pleasant men’s cologne. Very nice.

But the thought that my long-time school crush might already have a girlfriendโ€”one whoโ€™d reached the point of receiving boxes like thatโ€”made my chest ache.

I shoved the box toward him without thinking and, sourly, blurted, โ€œWell, wish you and your girlfriend happiness.โ€

Out of a peculiar jealous streak, I dragged heavy emphasis onto โ€œhappiness,โ€ hinting at what I meant.

He froze a beat, thenโ€”unexpectedlyโ€”answered, โ€œDonโ€™t get the wrong idea. I donโ€™t have a girlfriend.โ€

No girlfriend?

Iโ€™d already told myself, during our phone call, that Iโ€™d lied. โ€œThen this box isโ€”โ€ I pointed at the taped-up delivery in his arms.

Ethan didnโ€™t answer right away. Instead he asked, โ€œDidnโ€™t you sayโ€ฆyou didnโ€™t open the package?โ€

I hesitated, then tried to deflect. โ€œThatโ€™s not the point. You still havenโ€™t answered my question.โ€

Silence from him this time.

A few seconds later he awkwardly rubbed his nose. โ€œI donโ€™t know how to explainโ€ฆ Anyway, itโ€™s not how you think.โ€

I took a moment to process that and then smiled. No girlfriendโ€”good. That meant I still had a chance.

I believe in seizing opportunities. So I went on the offensive.

โ€œSorry again for taking your package. How about I buy you a meal as compensation?โ€

To my surprise, Ethan nodded and agreed.

He carried that box Iโ€™d opened and resealed, following me into the cafeteria.

It was a little late, so the dining hall wasnโ€™t crowded. I kept telling myself to be brave and slowly closed the distance between us.

Ethan didnโ€™t seem to notice; even when my sleeve brushed his arm, he just held the box and didnโ€™t react.

I chickened out and stopped inching closer.

After circling the serving area, we agreed to try the newly opened sauerkraut fish at the cafeteria.

We sat down.

While waiting for the food, Ethan thumbed his phone quietly. I pretended to look at my phone but stole glances at him.

He had that boyish qualityโ€”pure and charming, clean and elegant. Every look at him made the world seem a little brighter.

Sensing my gaze, he seemed a bit nervous, holding his phone in one hand and lightly rubbing his fingertips.

I found myself staring at his hands.

Long, neat fingers, rounded, clean nailsโ€”no dirt under them at all. His pinky nails werenโ€™t grown out.

Not surprisingโ€”my crushโ€™s details all fit my aesthetic perfectly.

I was lost in it when he suddenly looked up. Our eyes met.

To ease the awkwardness, I pretended not to know him and asked, โ€œWhich year are you in?โ€

He took that seriously and introduced himself, โ€œIโ€™m Ethan Carter, a sophomore.โ€

I already knew thatโ€”even his birthdayโ€”September 29, Libraโ€”he liked sour and sweet foods.

But I played dumb and feigned surprise, โ€œOh, youโ€™re a year younger than me, underclassman.โ€

Ethan didnโ€™t look surprised. He just said calmly, โ€œAnd you are?โ€

โ€œClaire Bennett.โ€

I worried my name was too ordinary to remember, but unexpectedly he smiled. โ€œItโ€™s niceโ€”just like you. Very sweet.โ€

Sweet?

My heart lurched. He called me sweet!

He must be flirting with me!

Flush with that almost shameless excitement, I added Ethan on WeChat and tried to learn more about him.

He was truly cleanโ€”his looks, his moments online, even his dating past.

He said heโ€™d only had one relationship, and theyโ€™d ended cleanly. A total treasure of an underclassman.

But the dayโ€™s surprises werenโ€™t over.

Just then a boy walked over and clapped a hand on Ethanโ€™s shoulder. โ€œI forgot my keys. No oneโ€™s in the dormโ€”did you bring keys?โ€

Ethan nodded and pulled a key from his pocket.

The boy took it and, as he was leaving, glanced at the huge taped box on the table and laughed, โ€œAlready here? Iโ€™ll tell the others to come back early. Weโ€™ll open it tonight.โ€

I sat there raw for a long moment before the realization hitโ€”Ethan had said he didnโ€™t have a girlfriend, but he hadnโ€™t said he didnโ€™t have boyfriend(s).

It took a few seconds to register that shocking truth, and then Iโ€”

Wimped out and ran.

Call it inability to process: I couldnโ€™t accept that the pure, moonlit underclassman Iโ€™d crushed on liked men. And not just oneโ€”he seemed to be involved with several.

My youth wasnโ€™t just over; it collapsed.

I walked back to the dorm so fast I probably beat my high school race-walking record.

Inside, I tore off my shoes, dove under the covers, and buried my head. What a shocking, sad day.

I never thought Iโ€™d be the one eating drama about my crushโ€”especially such explosive drama. A few minutes later my phone buzzed.

It was Ethan.

I hesitated and then let the call go to voicemail. I couldnโ€™t face himโ€”not yet. Then a WeChat message came.

I opened it slowly.

โ€œClaire, I donโ€™t know how to explain. Itโ€™s not what you thinkโ€”one or two sentences wonโ€™t do. How about I buy you dinner tonight and explain everything?โ€

I wavered. Should I go?

I pulled a coin from my pocket and, on a whim, decided Iโ€™d let it decideโ€”heads means yes.

When the coin landed and showed the floral side, I flipped it quickly to the other side and typed back, โ€œOkay. Send me the address.โ€

Who actually lets a coin decide? Of course notโ€”I just needed that split second to figure out what I wanted.

I still had an afternoon class. After that I rushed back, showered, did my makeup, and finally chose a white dress.

Ethan reserved a private room at The Neighborhood Bistroโ€”the third room on the left on the second floor.

Pushing open the door, I immediately saw him seated at the table.

I was surprised to see him leaning back slightly with a cigarette burning halfway between his fingers.

Iโ€™d watched him so long and never knownโ€”Ethan smoked.

When he heard the door, he looked up and, seeing me, instinctively stubbed the cigarette out. He seemed briefly choked by the smoke and coughed a little.

He stood, waved the smoke away, and pulled out a chair for me.

โ€œItโ€™s a bit late; I thought you might be hungry, so I ordered a few things. Tell me if itโ€™s to your taste; we can add more.โ€

He handed me the menu as he said it.

Honestly, I was a little overwhelmedโ€”there were already five dishes and a soup on the table. There was no way the two of us could finish it all.

"No need," I said, closing the menu and pushing it aside. I sat at the table, propping my chin on my hand, and looked at him. "You’re really not…?"

I was just too curious.

All afternoon Iโ€™d been turning it over in my head and couldnโ€™t guess. If it wasnโ€™t what I imagined, then what was it?

Bought for his roommate?

Then why would his roommate say something like "weโ€™ll use it up together tonight"?

That kind of wolfish talk… I stared at Ethan, waiting for his answer.

His pale face flushed instantly.

He looked away and stammered an explanation. "Thereโ€™s really nothingโ€”my bunkmate watched a video online saying you can blow this thing like a balloon and fill it with water so it gets huge. We were just curious, so we bought one to try…"

I was stunned.

Iโ€™d considered every possibility and never expected such a childish truth.

"Really?"

Ethan sat up straight, his expression so earnest it was hard not to believe him. "Really."

He rubbed the tip of his nose; his cheeks still had that suspicious flush. "It was just a dumb immature guy joke. Donโ€™t think too much about it…"

Okay, fine. I wouldnโ€™t overthink it.

I couldnโ€™t help but smile a little, and the more I thought about it, the cuter Ethan seemed.

And knowing he didnโ€™t have any weird habit at least let me completely relax.

Words slipped out before I could stop them. "So… youโ€™re not, like, an XL, then?"

At my question, Ethan seemed to flush even harder.

This underclassman, a year younger than me, looked unbearably adorable all pink and embarrassedโ€”like the cuddly British shorthair cat I used to have.

I wanted to ruffle his hair.

After hemming and hawing for a bit, he finally spoke in a voice so low I barely heard it.

I strained to listen and caught: "I… I should be about the same…"

My eyes lit up. Hahโ€”little brother, thatโ€™s awfully confident.

The next two days, Ethan and I barely made any progress.

Aside from a couple of morning and goodnight messages, we didn’t talk. I tried a few times to start conversations but gave up each time because I couldn’t find the right words.

A week later, my roommate dragged me to sign up for the swim team, and I unexpectedly ran into Ethan.

In… swim trunks.

Guiltyโ€”I couldnโ€™t help glancing more than once. My heart skipped.

Damn.

Turns out the underclassman’s confidence wasnโ€™t without reason.

It was too embarrassing to stare, so I quickly looked away.

Since Ethan was there, I decided against making my usual escape.

They say the best chances are the closest onesโ€”plus, you have to wear swimsuits in the water.

Iโ€™m fairly confident in my figure.

Slim waist, long legs, perkyโ€”walking around in a swimsuit in front of Ethan would be the least I could do for myself.

But just as I changed into my suit and before I could show off, I fell into the pool.

There were a lot of people by the pool. Someone brushed hard against my left shoulder as they walked by.

I didnโ€™t even have time to react before I plunged into the deep end.

Most importantlyโ€”I swear I canโ€™t swim!

The second I hit the water my mind went blank. Instinct took over and I started thrashing. In the panic I heard another splash nearby and then a person appeared in my vision.

The face looked a little like Ethanโ€™s.

He swam over quickly and grabbed me.

In a life-or-death moment your survival instinct is powerful; I had no time to think. Almost reflexively I clung to the person in front of me, legs wrapped around his waist, arms locked around his neck.

I swear at that moment I had no idea who he was and no intention of taking advantageโ€”just pure instinct to cling to anyone keeping me afloat.

But "instinct" didnโ€™t seem to be mine alone.

He struggled to carry me to the shallow end and then lifted me out.

When our bodies left the water I was still frozen in that pose, mind completely blank, until I turned my head and relaxed.

It was Ethan holding meโ€”and his face had gone beet red, the skin behind his ears flushed bright.

I knew why he was embarrassed.

I watched him for a few seconds, then leaned close to his ear and lowered my voice. "Calm down, underclassman…"

Premium chapters locked

Unlock the rest of the story

200 Book Coins

The next scene of Wrong Package, Right Crush begins with: He stiffened. His ears were a blaze of red…. Continue with the remaining 360 story sections.

Get Book Coins to Unlock